Happy to lose both. I think Clark could be a good player but not at st Kilda. Long is a genuine spud.

GC have pick 7 & 25 currently They will get alot for Rankine when he goes, maybe a first and second? I think we should demand their lowest 2nd rounder as a minimum. If Clark is going too, and hopefully he isn't, we'd probably do better to trade him to GC than North and get one of their FRDPs an...

Only once has DeGoey got over 400 disposals in a season (2021) ..... over his career he has averaged 17.5 disposals 4marks 3 tackles and 1.27 goals a game ...... he is pretty much a glorified Half Forward who can light it up occasionally with the odd centre square appearance ....... is this output ...

We cannot afford to rebuild We’d be like Hawthorn or North Melbourne for 3 years Then maybe 3 years climbing And what guarantees that we would even climb It would be our death knell I read a post here a little while ago that said we had turned over 23 players since the end of 2019. Is that the case...

We cannot afford to rebuild We’d be like Hawthorn or North Melbourne for 3 years Then maybe 3 years climbing And what guarantees that we would even climb It would be our death knell I read a post here a little while ago that said we had turned over 23 players since the end of 2019. Is that the case...

We cannot afford to rebuild We’d be like Hawthorn or North Melbourne for 3 years Then maybe 3 years climbing And what guarantees that we would even climb It would be our death knell 100% agree. Particularly with the tassie discussion going on. Imagine if we were in a similar position to north, ther...

Possible trade Swap north pick 1 for our pick 9 plus Hill We split pick 1 into pick 7 and say 13 We split 13 into 18 and 30 We get 3 picks inside 30 And yes north could do the swap of pick 1 and give us pick 13 instead North drop a few spots and get hill Only possible if clarko gets there obviously...

C A C+ List A C- Coaching set up I hoped finals, I believed finals to be the minimum with everything going right. Sadly as the season evolved the realisation was glaring in our lack of player development, conditioning of players, extremely glaring holes in our list (KP Fwd / KP Bck / Goalkicking mi...

I was thinking to myself tonight. What is Clark’s role in this team going to be going forward? We already have two half back loose playing flankers who I think most (including the st Kilda coaching team) clearly view as better options. Clark is not a good a shut down defensive player and is better ...

I was thinking to myself tonight. What is Clark’s role in this team going to be going forward? We already have two half back loose playing flankers who I think most (including the st Kilda coaching team) clearly view as better options. Clark is not a good a shut down defensive player and is better ...

I was thinking to myself tonight. What is Clark’s role in this team going to be going forward? We already have two half back loose playing flankers who I think most (including the st Kilda coaching team) clearly view as better options. Clark is not a good a shut down defensive player and is better w...

Don’t blame Gears for hanging around..for delicately timing his stepping-down-as-capitan announcement (after lists were finalized)… Sure, personally, maybe he shouldn’t have been on the list this year. But it is St Kilda’s weaknesss not to stand up to Gears’s manager. The Football Department is wea...

Thanks for the service. Although still think it was incredibly selfish that he collected a pay check and took a list spot knowing full well he was going nowhere near the senior side this season. I love supporters like you, who think they know about footy… when in fact…. I can just see you with your...

:cry: Thanks for the service. Although still think it was incredibly selfish that he collected a pay check and took a list spot knowing full well he was going nowhere near the senior side this season. Take a hike clown. If Geary wasn't injured he'd be in the mix to play. He’s been close to Sandy’s ...

Thanks for the service. Although still think it was incredibly selfish that he collected a pay check and took a list spot knowing full well he was going nowhere near the senior side this season. After what he's put himself through for this club? Seriously!? The broken legs, injuries etc, another ye...

:cry: Thanks for the service. Although still think it was incredibly selfish that he collected a pay check and took a list spot knowing full well he was going nowhere near the senior side this season. Take a hike clown. If Geary wasn't injured he'd be in the mix to play. He’s been close to Sandy’s w...

Thanks for the service. Although still think it was incredibly selfish that he collected a pay check and took a list spot knowing full well he was going nowhere near the senior side this season. After what he's put himself through for this club? Seriously!? The broken legs, injuries etc, another ye...

Ernie is right ...we are cooked .. We are worse than cooked. We have repeated the same mistake we made with Richo. The board needs to be held accountable for this and resign. Satan does a s*** job but gets promoted from COO to CEO. Ratts does a s*** job but gets a 2 year extension. Is it jobs for t...

Ernie is right ...we are cooked .. We are worse than cooked. We have repeated the same mistake we made with Richo. The board needs to be held accountable for this and resign. Satan does a s*** job but gets promoted from COO to CEO. Ratts does a s*** job but gets a 2 year extension. Is it jobs for t...

Thanks for the service. Although still think it was incredibly selfish that he collected a pay check and took a list spot knowing full well he was going nowhere near the senior side this season.

Ernie is right ...we are cooked .. We are worse than cooked. We have repeated the same mistake we made with Richo. The board needs to be held accountable for this and resign. Satan does a s*** job but gets promoted from COO to CEO. Ratts does a s*** job but gets a 2 year extension. Is it jobs for t...

Ernie is right ...we are cooked .. We are worse than cooked. We have repeated the same mistake we made with Richo. The board needs to be held accountable for this and resign. Satan does a s*** job but gets promoted from COO to CEO. Ratts does a s*** job but gets a 2 year extension. Is it jobs for t...

Yes we are poorly ran and coached at the moment. But we are perennial underdogs (given funding, prestidge ect..). As fans we should take pride in knowing we support a team no matter what and that one day when we eventually win a flag will be the greatest day of our lives.

Both reviews this quarter... He’s right freakin there!! The Carlton goal that they questioned hitting the post, he was in prime position to make the call. That’s quite literally the job he’s trained to do. If he can’t call either on the line, what hope does the game have. Just make a decision. Dear...

The sky is falling, the sky is falling!!! Wow, we have two losses and we want to strip the place bare and start again? Honestly, you people. If your partner failed to cook you a tasty meal two nights in a row you would kick them out, destroy all the pots and pans and burn down the kitchen Mate we’v...