Dan Warna wrote:pretty sure he does some stuff for the swines.

I think he came up for the Team of the Decade dinner a couple of months back, but beyond that they don't see sight nor sound of him either.

homework wrote:whelan hasnt benn to the tribunal as much as bakes sadly

No and we are all very happy about that over here !!!

Very well put QueenC. You continue to be one of the few 'reasoned voices' from over at Demonland. Thanks Mr Magic....... And I understand and agree that there are some fundamental differences in the cases. But there was no intention on Whelans behalf to hurt Ball and he was trying to deliver what i...

Ok first things first, I am a Melbourne supporter........ But all bias aside I have to say that I had absolutely no problem with what Whelan did. He shepherded Ball (perhaps illegally on the day, but that really isn't the point) and they unfortunately clashed heads. It was an unfortunate outcome of ...

Panel said they believed Baker...but judged his action in stopping as reckless Question: Weren't Johnson's actions deemed as intentional? Question: Then how does Baker receive a virtually identical penalty (Johnson had 90 carryover pts, Baker 155)? What a farce. Joke. Actually Johnsons actions were...

Surely week in week out we're shown that infact all players who front the tribunal are guilty and must prove their innocence. Week in week out we are shown that a number of incidents which bare a striking similarity to each other are viewed completely differently when being acted out by different p...

pity he didn't break farmers jaw then What the odds of him actually lining up this week anyway? Depends what time he makes bail..... Hee :lol: !!! But Farmer always rips the Dees in half and while I think we have a snowballs chance in hell of winning, life would be better if he wasn't on the ground...

Dan Warna wrote: pity he didn't break farmers jaw then

What the odds of him actually lining up this week anyway?

Dan Warna wrote:the buckley sees all, the buckley knows all...

And everyone always seems to pay way too much attention !!!

Scott Burns is a quality bloke. Did you see him hand the ball to Neitz on Friday night? Quality. I saw that and was really impressed, especially given what had happened that night. It was refreshing to see him show some respect to another clubs legend on what was essentially his milestone night. Bu...

They are not a witness for fremantle, they are a witness for the AFL. The Fremantle footy club is not charging Baker the AFL is. correct..... Witness for the AFL or not he still works for Fremantle. Right? So how can anyone associated with an involved club give unbiased or untainted testimony in re...

Witness or not, footage is key and the only unbiased evidence, and there isn't any of what ever may or may not have happened between Baker and Farmer. I can't see him getting too much, if anything hopefully for your sake. As for Johnson - got what he deserved for such a god awful and dangerous act. ...

I wish he wasn't needed to play next week (and I would prefer it if he didn't) but we are quickly running out of players !!!

Dirty, flogging little arse wipe.......but I could be more than a little biased :wink: !!! That being said if he doesn't serve at least six weeks with his thumb up his butt then there is a real problem, as this is exactly the attack on a player that the AFL have been so public about wanting to take ...

I marched in the Pink Lady......

It was amazing and really emotional out there and it was one of those experiences that I will never forget.

I was proud to be a part of it !!!

There is no way around it, that was a bloody awful decision !!!

How is Attard after the heavy hit he took last night?

Agree. But there were some home town decisions. What about the Hall assualt on Dal Santo's head paid as holding the ball ? :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil: There are always going to be some ridiculous hometown calls, even in Melbourne...... But that was an absolute shocker of a decision and there was no...