Baker incident should have gone to court ....end of story !! Was personally very irate at our previous admin for not showing some conscience on this matter. The greatest injustice for mine of all time was Barry HAll being allowed to play in the Grand Final in 05. THis is when I realised the AFL was ...

if Barks can go on nuerotically and obsessively about GT leaving why cant NExus do the same about GT coming home. This is an issue which will grow and grow and grow the lower we go on the ladder so I wouldnt keep running from it. The biggest single issue in the last 5 or so years at the club so unde...

Excellent initial post. Cant believe the optimism on this site after being 'walloped' and toyed with by the cats. We have a few delusional members on this site who still believe we are on the right track with a negative game plan and a second rate ruck division which is either injured or rejected fr...

Our younger players then were actually harder in 2004.....yet now they are bigger and stronger Lyon is getting less out of them.
Explain why BArks and co !

Some very sad posters here trying to explain that we are better off now than we were before. ...... so is Iraq I suppose!!!! These posters should do honourable thing and disappear. Hoe are we better off now than when were were ????? Blindness and foolish pride are no excuse for being in the bottom h...

Ever bothered to take a look at our recruiting under Thomas numbnuts? Yeah ever bothered to consider our recruiting......forget where we were on the ladder....it was our recruiting that really matters. In fact stuff the premiership.....as long as we can win the award for the best recruiters I will ...

Excellent post which gives gets we [cynics] nodding our head. Remember there are a lot of tools who support our beloved team too if that is consolation to you. You'll find a few of them on this site if you upset them. As for the umps ...couldnt agree more. Far too noticeable with their flurescent sh...

Its certainly not where we want to be at this stage

Fair points but the real issue is why is the team not firing up because of it. Look at Carlton today after their boy was knocked out. Sammy Hamil must be squirming after watching the treatment dished out and the lack of response from our boys,,especially on the scoreboard. SUcks to me !

Is there any surprise that RL went out and secured a player like Schneider who has better footskills and ability to snag goals than many already at the Saints??? And its like yeah ...where are we now with Schneider,. Ccompletely missing the point here by wanting to drag peripheral elements of a pre...

A very well presneted lucid argument Rodgerfox which is really intimidating many an anti GT faction. Lest we forget the reasons we brought in Lyon was to become tacticully more proficient. Seems some people forgot what we were good at in the first place.

Of course its a simple game just ask Leigh Matthews who is staggered by the amounnt of traffic on/off the bench these days ....but then again what would he know? We can ask the visionaries who recruited Lyon and company why we have followed this path over the last year or so at the expense of a team...

Tactically obsessed and way too soft. Why are we allowing our guys to get knocked out unchecked? Can someone explain how and why we are dropping off the radar and the Doggies and Geelong are moving ahead in leaps and bounds. We are simply stagnating. Didnt we put heaps of dosh up to get the best coa...

I thought we got rid of the old brains trust to bring in the new and better brains trust. I thought we were terribly out coached last night. Am scratchin my head here......

we're talkin best player tonight by a mile .....am a big fan of this guy !

Definately an issue the AFL should be more democratic about in my view.

MAybe we will pick up a few KAngaroos supporters in the wash.
I insist however they must wear their false teeth at games.
Otherwise we sit 'em with Barks and Joffaboy !

True St.Kilda never played so well defensively as they did in '07 ................and never play so bad in atack as they did in '07 ! So where did that leave us. Lower on the ladder than '06 despite a better team on the field all year, a better draw and supposedly better coaching staff. MAke no mist...

Fireman...dont you know its unSt.Kilda to support someone who took us to two preliminary finals only to be beaten by 2 teams who romped it in on Grand Final Day. We are scared of success and must deride anyone who nearly gets us there. Look at the character assasination on this site and look at the ...

a real sit on the fence article if ever there was one. Doesnt want to give full credit or criticism one way or the other. Living proof why journalists are journalists who sit and commentate and dont have to make a decision and not be 'active players' in the game. And the good ruckman available at th...

Not really into them myself. Bit of a distraction if you ask me. We're kinda goin down Eddy's pathway,.....putting hype before substance. Would rather go about things quietly and get the points without fanfare.... Now if its about adding to our kitty then why not try something new, different and ori...

Hey that was me in the front row every body @!!!!

How did we sound ??

all the way with the G train

lots of clubs would love to have him believe me !!!

I certainly dont think she slept her way to the top........Who'd sleep with her ????

Dont even look st him 'Carltank' !