saintjake wrote:

CQ SAINT wrote:I will take it. Not sure GWS would though.

Pick 8 from GWS has been dubbed a sitting duck because they need to trade it to get enough points for the academy

Oh ok then.

One month ago I was happy we had picks 5 and 24 and thought we would snag a young gun and a good kid with a few tricks from the draft. Now I believe there is a strong possibility we could get a top young mid - 5 Freeman - 24 Rice - 45 promote Sinclair - 63 and risk Carlisle in the PSD for peanuts. ...

More than happy with pick five. I think Carlisle will be happy to go to the psd. He just cant say it. He will get much more security at a rebuilding club. Carlton Is rebuilding and was his second choice I would assume. He could have gone to Hawthorn at any stage. Reckon the PSD is fantasyland stuff...

I tend to think that with picks 9 and 28 for 5 on offer from Adelaide that if we wanted this deal done now we could do it. This makes me confident that we will not loose Carlisle or pick 5 and its look like he is gonna go to the PSD. Am l deluded? I don't think he will go in the PSD. I don't think ...

One month ago I was happy we had picks 5 and 24 and thought we would snag a young gun and a good kid with a few tricks from the draft. Now I believe there is a strong possibility we could get a top young mid - 5 Freeman - 24 Rice - 45 promote Sinclair - 63 and risk Carlisle in the PSD for peanuts. I...

I will take it. Not sure GWS would though.

57 points as a swinging KPP is a good season. Particular as he is new to defence. If he got votes defending its actually impressive.

I tend to think that with picks 9 and 28 for 5 on offer from Adelaide that if we wanted this deal done now we could do it. This makes me confident that we will not loose Carlisle or pick 5 and its look like he is gonna go to the PSD. Am l deluded? I don't think he will go in the PSD. I don't think ...

I tend to think that with picks 9 and 28 for 5 on offer from Adelaide that if we wanted this deal done now we could do it. This makes me confident that we will not loose Carlisle or pick 5 and its look like he is gonna go to the PSD. Am l deluded?

Diodoro is exhibiting all the qualities of a desperate man.

Instant cult hero.

[quote="Rosco"]If they renamed it father-illegitimate son we may have been in with a go.[/quote Seriously though. I would be seriously perplexed if we dont get him. He is not an Ablett but he is ours. It should be his right. I havent got a good argument really. I have to admit this is all ...

As I said. The rule is supposed to protect tradition. This kind of crud just makes a mockery of the whole notion. He made a choice, it should be honoured. If not then dont give him the choice. Put it this way. If I chose St.Kilda cause my dad played there and someone made a bid for me the Saints co...

If Bailey Rice doesn't end up at St.Kilda by his own choice then the rule should be scrapped. What a load of shite. Didn't we all whinge that the rule was too generous when Geelong got Ablett, Hawkins, Scarlett? Now they tighten up the rule and we whinge again that its not generous enough. When we ...

I didn't whine about any of them. The rule is about protecting and creating traditions. Either give them the choice or put them in the draft with everyone else and get rid of the rule. We will get him.

If Bailey Rice doesn't end up at St.Kilda by his own choice then the rule should be scrapped. What a load of shite.

I'm confident that Carlton will move on from Rice and focus their picks else where. SOS has bigger fish to fry. He and Freeman are ours. Pick 24 and player for Carlisle or double down with pick 5 and get Carlisle and a kid. Otherwise he goes to the ps draft and we take the best mid for 5. Its a win/...

2 games in a row in Queensland. Worth a week off for me and the family. Purely selfish but I am sure my fellow Qld Saints wouldn't mind.

I've seen 100 guys come and go where there is an 'if he could' and 'he should do this' about their game. Some of them work and work to improve and make it. They are rare. This is the plight of Seb Ross. He has it all ahead of him. I hope he makes it. My argument is that this is also what makes him a...

I couldn't imagine there has ever been a more inspirational or successful example of leadership at this club in my life time (born in 70). I might be wrong. But I would expect that the only way Roo should not be chosen as captain is if he rules himself out of contention. Personally, he is still the ...

What makes you think he will be an elite midfielder? He has the quickest hands on our list and is one of the best handballers I have seen at the saints in over 60 years. I believe he can be as good as Mitchell in this area, Besides the coach loves him. "Last week, Richardson spoke of the club’...

What makes you think he will be an elite midfielder? He has the quickest hands on our list and is one of the best handballers I have seen at the saints in over 60 years. I believe he can be as good as Mitchell in this area, Besides the coach loves him. "Last week, Richardson spoke of the club’...

Well it looks like its done. He is gonna nominate St.Kilda

Dont get me wrong. He is a good kid. But not first or second pick as an inside mid.

[quote="BigMart"]Greg Williams best attribute was.....?[/quote
Getting the ball. I dont see any comparison. Lovely hands is good but you gotta get the ball first.