zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz .....I hear the same thing over and over and over..."didn't try", "shouldn't wear the jumper"..... blah blah There is a science to a great team in any code....Talented, Intelligent, and fierce players It's very simple...we have a raft of duds left over from the...

If he gets a decent contract do we get a draft pick - or does he just go now ? No compensation because we delisted him What do you mean? Delisting him IS the compensation Now that is harsh. Funny, but harsh. Harsh, but true. The humour element went out the window for me a few years ago now :(

outside66 wrote: ↑Fri 25 Oct 2019 2:11pm

saint6709 wrote: ↑Fri 25 Oct 2019 2:05pm If he gets a decent contract do we get a draft pick - or does he just go now ?

No compensation because we delisted him

What do you mean? Delisting him IS the compensation

Newnes has dropped off a bit since 2017, whether it was the concussions, shoulder, lost confidence, and/or not played in his best position. However if he gets back to his 2016 & 17 form, when he came 5th and 8th in the B & F in a side that was just outside the 8, he will be in Carlton's 22....

Thank God we won't have to face the team selection on a Thursday night and see J.Newnes on there, followed by 15 ineffectual touches and 4 turnovers, 3 missed tackles, 2 dropped marks and 3 behinds from set shots on game day. Good luck to him, maybe he will pick up his progress again, but he was fi...

Please please please Carlton... take Newnes!!
I'll even throw in a set of steak knives!!!

desertsaint wrote: ↑Sun 21 Jul 2019 8:17pm Drop him. Long in - Newnes out. Only change needed.

Agree

Anyway, WELL DONE SAINTS!!! Great work!!

For all the Newnes fan boys... nice falcon

Newnes has also had very good games at AFL level so no reason why he can't deliver on that again. Is very versatile too. Remember the games where he was sat in F50 and took contested marks and kicked bags of goals. I believe Newnes best is ahead of him. I don't. He is the turnover king. His decisio...

Newnes has also had very good games at AFL level so no reason why he can't deliver on that again. Is very versatile too. Remember the games where he was sat in F50 and took contested marks and kicked bags of goals. I believe Newnes best is ahead of him. I don't. He is the turnover king. His decisio...

Newnes has also had very good games at AFL level so no reason why he can't deliver on that again. Is very versatile too. Remember the games where he was sat in F50 and took contested marks and kicked bags of goals. I believe Newnes best is ahead of him. I don't. He is the turnover king. His decisio...

With this side, and positioning of players, I expect another loss. Gresham in the middle will look lost, and Newnes on the ground will bear the same rotten fruit. After another few losses - Only a matter of time before some posters begin to bag Ratten as the reason for failure...when it's just a C g...

I think there’s probably a bit of pain still to come before we turn the corner, but the right thing has happened this week for sure Especially for Newnes and Acres If Newnes and Acres are dropped this week, my confidence in the integrity of the match committee will begin to grow again. No more Rich...

Acres in the guts (NOT rucking) and Gresh up forward would be nice. Yeah play Acres in the middle because we need someone who only runs when they can be bothered doing so, has no defensive accountability and is just lazy. Most overrated player on this forum I actually tend to agree... trade if poss...

1. Gresh up forward where he belongs 2. Acres in the guts 3. More games into Coffield and Clarke 4. Drop Newnes...for good 5. Drop D Mac 6. No more favorites in the core C grade senior group 7. Give games to players based on performance, rather than 'loyalty' 8. Recruit gun mids, and begin to phase ...

Club plant...laughable for starters. The problem is that your criticism of Newnesy is very abnormal and highly below the belt which the forum puts up with daily and weekly. So...as I said, take your criticism to his face. Give it a go champ! 'Highly abnormal' LMAO The only highly abnormal thing aro...

You hear that everyone...if you have any opinions or criticism on the club, or a player, go down there and pick a fight. This obviously applies to all aspects of life....so if you have a problem with the prime minister, for example , march up to Canberra, punch his security guards in the face and be...

Battle. Austin (or Clav). White Roberton. Carlisle. Coffield Clark. Acres. Hannebery Membrey. McCartin. Billings Gresham. Bruce. Good question Marshall. Steele. Steven King. Dunstan Bytel. Draft Pick 1 Of those 12 played tonight Hopefully Round 1 in 2020 will look something like this (fingers and t...

Newnes should be given another year - under a totally new coaching regime the thing thats sticks in my craw is that this club seems to lauding him, and gifting him the games, as they player he should have become, not what he actually is and what s***s me more is that they expect us to swallow and a...

tedtheodorelogan2018 wrote: ↑Sat 13 Jul 2019 11:47pm Yep, keep bagging a 150 servant game of our club bud. Real legend!

Servants don't get paid around 700k a year my 'friend'.

The true servants are the faithful who have been dealing with this garbage for years.... they are called 'members' old pal o mine.

Forget the 150th and Newnes. Coming on straight after the siren is loserville activity!!! You seem to have a tiny hard-on for numbers divisible by 50 Ted ol 'buddy'. You see, I couldn't give a flying f%$k how many games someone has played.... whether it's 1 or 1000, it's HOW they've been played. .....

Newnes and Acres delist.

Every one else good effort...good to see Hunter show some signs.

Another awful season almost over.

Hey Ted buddy ol pal... your Newnes played yet another game of rubbish....turns the ball over constantly, and loses every one on one contest he 'participates in.

Happy 150th ... give him a medal

Damn Newnes.... just so bad

You don't get it. It's about respect buddy. Pure and simple. Any idiot can have an opinion (especially these days with internet). You have no respect for Newnes which I find bizarre. The guy has played a 150 games of AFL footy - the highest standard possible and in one of the physically most demand...