The club has gotten rid of about 1/5 of the playing list and most of the senior coaches this off-season. They are clearly doing something about a problem, so why can't people be optimistic about it? Should we continue to bag the club even as they make changes? You can't be serious. The only player ...

The club has gotten rid of about 1/5 of the playing list and most of the senior coaches this off-season. They are clearly doing something about a problem, so why can't people be optimistic about it? Should we continue to bag the club even as they make changes? You can't be serious. The only player ...

I would go Smith

His playing style is almost Judd-esque and he breaks lines better than Rozee and Rankin

He is fierce in his attack at the ball, and also a tackling machine.

He is a beautiful kick of the ball too...and he is from Vic

However, if you believe, as I do, that the club is clearly getting its s*** together (imo made clear by a plethora of off-season additions off the field and a clear shift in direction), then power to you as well! Why silence someone for positivity? The same negativity was coming from all angles pri...

The club has gotten rid of about 1/5 of the playing list and most of the senior coaches this off-season. They are clearly doing something about a problem, so why can't people be optimistic about it? Should we continue to bag the club even as they make changes? You can't be serious. The only player ...

The club has gotten rid of about 1/5 of the playing list and most of the senior coaches this off-season. They are clearly doing something about a problem, so why can't people be optimistic about it? Should we continue to bag the club even as they make changes? You can't be serious. The only player ...

http://m.afl.com.au/news/2018-03-17/crystal-ball-aflcomaus-2018-predictions Read through this. This is why you don't worry about ladder predictions and this was done in mid March. Not one person picked West Coast to make the 8. Only 1 for Collingwood and they had them at 8th. Do not write off the S...

I'm liking this!

desertsaint wrote: ↑Thu 18 Oct 2018 10:00am theodore always consistent in talking us up. fair enough.
but then trolls another club's trading performance. other club completely outperforms us in trading.
stick to just talking us up, and instantly half your mistakes ted!

haha so true...club plant

http://m.afl.com.au/news/2018-03-17/crystal-ball-aflcomaus-2018-predictions Read through this. This is why you don't worry about ladder predictions and this was done in mid March. Not one person picked West Coast to make the 8. Only 1 for Collingwood and they had them at 8th. Do not write off the S...

Awesome news for supporters - bad luck for Mav
Newnes, Armitage and Savage next please

God I'd love that trade to happen... but even the Gold Coast aren't desperate enough to take that list of duds....pity

The funniest thing is if they did take those players, they would finish bottom in 2019 instead of second bottom.

If Newnes was traded to another club. his absence would have no affect on the team, at all. He won't be going anywhere, he'll be like Geelong's Menzel, no one wants him so he stays put. Agree - although I strongly believe Newnes leaving would make a difference - in the positive. Younger players lik...

Sainternist wrote: ↑Thu 11 Oct 2018 4:38pm With Billy Slater now at the club, perhaps Newnes will be instructed to apply more defensive pressure and tackle harder.

An AFL player needs to be instructed to do that? really?

Many Newnes fans on here - not sure how or why...all you have to do is watch him play. It's important to pretend that the player we're discussing is wearing another jumper - say Newnes played for Brisbane for example - not St Kilda Now ask yourself: "Do I want this player wearing a Saints jumpe...

If our recruiters don't pick Rankine , they haven't learnt a thing

Whatever sponsors we had left would surely bail, after he stabs someone in a nightclub

Dare Iced Coffee anyone?

They wouldn't even want or need him if Natanui was injured and Lycett left. Remember that. We did very well to get pick 39 for an average ruckman that could barely get a game in a bottom 6 side. Plus it frees up 600k. Win win. Why do posters just explode on here without analysing the situation corr...

Jesus, no money in the world will attract an A grader to our basket case dribbling club. All good, I'm actually happy that we've kept pick #4 - but I have no faith in our recruiters getting it right. Going to be a long 2019...the upside, is that Richo will be gone by about round 6. The funniest tho...

Jesus, no money in the world will attract an A grader to our basket case dribbling club. All good, I'm actually happy that we've kept pick #4 - but I have no faith in our recruiters getting it right. Going to be a long 2019...the upside, is that Richo will be gone by about round 6. The funniest thou...

Some have the heart for it, some don't. Good post. Straight from the snowflake playbook.... passive aggressive, self serving horsesh*t comment, implying that someone is deficient in either brain cells or heart if they disagree. Whoever you are, you are part of the problem at St.Kilda. Utterly agree...

A lot of Newnes fans here Not really all that sure if any of them have watched a game with him play, or perhaps they did , and thought he was someone else? Newnes never wins 1 on 1 contests, hardly ever tackles, is a ball watcher, and lacks any kind of X factor altogether. He performed incredibly po...

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE LET THIS BE TRUE!!!!
Get Hanners - WIN
Lose Newnes - HUUUUGE WIN!!!!!

...WIN WIN!!!!

2014 was a good year for us? Steele is the only player there that has had any form of impact. In fact 2014 was arguably one of the worst years, because of how many high draft picks we had, including number 1... and it's pretty obvious how that one turned out. High picks? We had 1, 21 and 22. Consid...

2014 was a good year for us?
Steele is the only player there that has had any form of impact.

In fact 2014 was arguably one of the worst years, because of how many high draft picks we had, including number 1... and it's pretty obvious how that one turned out.