Both samples tested positive, fact. Black and white. Naivety is no excuse. Lance, Tyson Gay, Sam Reilly, Ahmed Saad, Jobe Watson, Carl Lewis, RN, Thorpedo... All the same. By the way, I have nothing to complain about in my world, it is as good as you imagine. He deserves two years. Yeh right :roll: ...

Possibly, that'll be sorted in time. My thoughts re doping do not change whether it is one of our players or someone elses. He took a banned substance therefore should see the ban. He has no excuse at all.

ShanghaiSaint wrote:

ljpoyz wrote:He deserves two years.

Yeh right so sm is a rapistvaswell yeh

Re-read what Hallaj#3 said.

ShanghaiSaint wrote:

Hallalj#3 wrote:What's all this might talk? The kid is 20 and been outstanding is better then Jack at the same age both have similar attributes.

Will be on our list next yr..

Sorry jack is way above him. Let's not get too excited.

He deserves two years.

He is allowed to be listed, but who would want a fringe player from the 3rd worst side in the comp? He'd just be sitting on their list taking up a spot and $

Didn't know dyslexia was a speech impediment?

Teflon wrote:she struggles to say anything - the woman is dyslexic.

That isn't a big issue at all, small in comparison to your naivety to think even .5% of drug cheats test positive

saintspremiers wrote:The biggest issue is or HOW or why the Esssendon players NEVER tested positive??

A bit more of a work ethic is probably costing him more than dual positions I think Siposs is also the victim of some fairly inconsistent coaching drafted as a forward, trained as a forward, played early as a promising forward then suddenly becomes a BJ replacement, moves to HBF, plays irratically -...

Patton is more talented than those 4 combined.

Andreous wrote:Why would we want Patton. We need big backs and tough mids not another tall forward to go with Hickey, Stanley, Lee and White.

It isn't just our club, four clubs have been mentioned this year alone. And I have absolutely no doubt every club would have some type of issue.

AFL 360 saying it was from a protein shake that had "Amphetamine based products" in it.

On a day like today, I dont like your joke.

Dr Spaceman wrote:

ljpoyz wrote:Was Newnes rotated out with a broken jaw?

As long as he wasn't rotated out with a humongous jaw. That's apparently the nudge, nudge, wink, wink juice sign

Was Newnes rotated out with a broken jaw?

That is not really true, the Olympic medalist usually get rolled on a retest of old blood/urine samples. The AFL's blood passport would b so insignificant that it won't be able to determine a pattern. It is PR speak. id say for now theres a diff depending on whether its been sent off to have its sec...

Some pretty naive points of view in this thread. PED use would be almost infinitely higher than the AFL or it's fans would want to recognise. There is no reason for the sport to be any different to others. The temptation for glory and riches is always strong and the game is perfect for PEDs. Now, pl...

Absolute best case scenario you'd get a pick in the 50s for either of them. In all seriousness though, what do people actually expect we'd get in return for the likes of a Stanley or a Siposs? Is this 'perceived potential' everyone's banging on about purely just our twisted perception? Who actually ...

This! Incredibly impressed with him so far, honestly believe he will be a gun. I think Newns was a massive positive. 26 touches, granted at half back but he will be a good player. Love Tom Lee. Gets the game just needs size and fitness Jack Steven is and always has been my new love child. He is awes...

It is like people are emotionally involved or something...

Macca isn't elite as a ruckman, at least not in the tap out side of the ruck duel. He is very good for his size around the ground though. Not saying I'd give him away for pick 27, for pick one, yep! The club has to exhaust every avenue to become a better side. If that means they trade Macca, then so...

The club has to exhaust every avenue to become a better side. If that means they trade Macca, then so be it.

Very true, everyone has their price. Some prices are extremely extremely expensive though. I believe you're on the mark here. If we get a trade offer that is clearly a win for the club, then the club must seek to trade. If not, then happily keep Dal. The reason to trade a player is If they want out,...

I believe you're on the mark here. If we get a trade offer that is clearly a win for the club, then the club must seek to trade. If not, then happily keep Dal. The reason to trade a player is If they want out, yes.... If they have currency and are surplus If we get an offer on them, which will lead ...

Jack Newnes, whether it is directly after Nick or after someone else does it for two year, will captain the club.

Looking very good in the Foxtel Cup. Obviously had some mental health issues whilst at Hawthorn,
mail is he has turned his life around and doing well these days. Still very young and looks a player
who would fit into our needed age bracket well.
Thoughts?

The club would take this deal in a second.