Watching the sprint live at the game, it looked like Wilson hit the tape first, and his reaction straight after suggested that he thought he did too. What did the tv show and was the replay definitive? It appeared that McReery was declared the winner almost immediately. Very confusing at the ground...

Dave, I have no idea where you get your figures for your cut and paste document that you regurgitate in your posts about this, but saying that St Kilda festival gets 700,000 people is some Donald Trump level exaggeration of crowd numbers, as the festival themselves say they had up to 375,000 people ...

The govt' $$$ poured into Linton Street shouldn't affect any move our club might one day make SW. As per with our previous ground at Outer Seaford (aka 'Halfway to Canberra' Oval :( ), the facilities funded at Moorabbin can be used by the community, and by community teams/groups. And no reason (at ...

According to Morris on channel 9, a number of players were adamant that he should not be pursued, the main one being Mason Wood who said he wouldn’t want him there going back to his time as a teammate of his.

Nick Dal and Hannah Priest also made it clear they didn’t want him around apparently.

Really, I find him a very reliable short kick. He goes short with probably half of his kicks, and pinpoints them well My observation was more from watching him live yesterday, when he got the ball in the backline a few times he just seemed to change his mind at the last second and spray it 30-40 me...

Would love to see Ari come back in and a great game also from Hugo Garcia today - what a little terrier he is, an amazing 14 tackles today! Ari worked reasonably hard to get free and provide run from behind and obviously it was a team instruction to get it to him so he can use his kicking as much a...

Nas W-M and mason wood in the stands, as well as Ross Lyon.

At the game, conditions haven’t been too bad since midway through the first quarter. Bloody cold but wind isn’t too bad. Poor skills all around though, Garcia looks the cleanest, Keeler been torched a couple of times going forward by bad decision making of others and Allison has spilled a few opport...

Not having Steele in the votes is extraordinary:

5- Marshall
4-Steele
3- membrey
2- Sinclair
1- wood

A word is just a word. Throw that word around a sporting field and it's purely a sledge. Why are the AFL being so stupid about a word? Stupid as in ramping up the penalty. Finlayson got 3, which was manifestly excessive. In law, no court in the damned world would give a harsher penalty to a crim fo...

A word is just a word. Throw that word around a sporting field and it's purely a sledge. Why are the AFL being so stupid about a word? Stupid as in ramping up the penalty. Finlayson got 3, which was manifestly excessive. In law, no court in the damned world would give a harsher penalty to a crim fo...

Curly your campaign on labelling umpires cheats is becoming Tiresome , it’s a delusion you can’t seem to shake off and causes many needless confrontations on here Did the umps witness the incident at the time it occurred? If not how could they call a free ? You don't think that Curly might...might....

Curly your campaign on labelling umpires cheats is becoming Tiresome , it’s a delusion you can’t seem to shake off and causes many needless confrontations on here Did the umps witness the incident at the time it occurred? If not how could they call a free ? You don't think that Curly might...might....

Here's the thing though. The umpiring didn't decide the match. It hardly ever does Only guys like CURLY try and turn every loss into an excuse to blame umpires. There's no point wallowing in self pity and whinging over every incorrect decision. We didn't need the umpires to win the game. We needed ...

Curly your campaign on labelling umpires cheats is becoming Tiresome , it’s a delusion you can’t seem to shake off and causes many needless confrontations on here Did the umps witness the incident at the time it occurred? If not how could they call a free ? You don't think that Curly might...might....

Here's the thing though. The umpiring didn't decide the match. It hardly ever does Only guys like CURLY try and turn every loss into an excuse to blame umpires. There's no point wallowing in self pity and whinging over every incorrect decision. We didn't need the umpires to win the game. We needed ...

All this talk about matching if its a end of first round compo, he is unrestricted so no matching is available. If he decides he wants to go to the hawks, thats what happens and we get what we are given.

My issue with the constant posting about umpires is that there is no recognition that they might make a mistake as humans. It is always ‘blatant cheating’. I don’t agree with every decision made, but I recognize that we also get calls in our favor that may be wrong. Curly seems incapable of either ...

My issue with the constant posting about umpires is that there is no recognition that they might make a mistake as humans. It is always ‘blatant cheating’. I don’t agree with every decision made, but I recognize that we also get calls in our favor that may be wrong. Curly seems incapable of either a...

CURLY wrote: ↑Fri 14 Jun 2024 10:39pm Get to 19 points

Two poor umpire decisions two goals to Brisbane


Steele getting held all night all good play on

You got vision of this holding or just guessing?

Terrible miss by Bonner, though, if it was 50 metre penalty why wasn't it Owen's kick? Actually thought that Bonner would have been better suited if the kick was 40-45 metres out. It’s either downfield to where the free was given or a 50 from where the ball was being kicked, whatever the bigger adv...

Terrible miss by Bonner, though, if it was 50 metre penalty why wasn't it Owen's kick? Actually thought that Bonner would have been better suited if the kick was 40-45 metres out. It’s either downfield to where the free was given or a 50 from where the ball was being kicked, whatever the bigger adv...

CURLY wrote: ↑Fri 14 Jun 2024 9:31pm I’m loving that Brisbane can mark fake multiple handballs but don’t get called to play in.

Please give it a rest, start your umpiring thread and post to your hearts content about the injustice you see

CURLY wrote: ↑Fri 14 Jun 2024 9:15pm

Brunswicksainter wrote: ↑Fri 14 Jun 2024 9:13pm How many more games are we giving this bonner prick

No in the back on Bonner

No to high on Wood


Laughable

Something is laughable, just not what you think it is

CURLY wrote: ↑Fri 14 Jun 2024 9:12pm SEN going ape s*** over the goal square infringement

Good to see you are not hung up on these things curly.