Collingwood are a 4 goal better side than Saints at the moment. Poor shooting for goal kept the Saints in it. They have a more practised system, more dangerous going forward, and smarter around the ball. It is only 5 weeks in, Saints are still bedding down their system, so there is a fair chance we...

Collingwood are a 4 goal better side than Saints at the moment. Poor shooting for goal kept the Saints in it. They have a more practised system, more dangerous going forward, and smarter around the ball. It is only 5 weeks in, Saints are still bedding down their system, so there is a fair chance we ...

Correct decisions made by the tribunal. Reasons fully explained by Tribunal Chairman. Sanity prevails. Very accident prone is Richmond’s Tom Lynch Lynch accidentally knocked out Keath …and he was protecting himself while ‘going for a mark’ He was also protecting himself when he accidentally elbowed...

Correct decisions made by the tribunal. Reasons fully explained by Tribunal Chairman. Sanity prevails.

As far as I’m concerned, Jones and Billings are done. Put a line through them. Have completely run out of patience with 5 years of ‘they’ll come good when they have a decent run with injury’. They’ll both return to Sandy after the bye. Give me 7 weeks of playing every week, peak fitness, with those...

It's a really interesting question, is Caminiti a better tall key forward than Max King?? Based on the 4 game sample so far you would have to answer in the affirmative, he appears to have a lot more confidence than Max, takes strong grabs and has a reliable action kicking for goal. When King become...

I totally agree with Malthouse. The way the AFL myriad of rules is going, we will have a bunch of boring robotrons running around like a computer game. I'd hate to be an umpire trying to interpret the rules.

Interested in the criticism of Hunter's on field time. Simplistic view: If there are 4 true mids/followers but only three can be on the field at once for balance doesn't that mean standard average game time would be 75% ( displaying my inability at complex math?). So 66% as stated means Hunter is g...

I wouldn’t consider “I can’t take this group anywhere” to be innocuous. The implication is that we are years away and he’s not renowned for patience. It adds credence to the other post on potential deep cuts to the list. It wouldn’t engender a high degree of enthusiasm amongst the playing group and...

SaintPav wrote: ↑Fri 04 Nov 2022 8:56am No it doesn’t.

Ridiculous post.

Suggest you avail yourself of your "membership rights" and get in touch with the club for a full description of Roughie's duties, objectives etc, etc for the interest of the forum.
I'm not fussed, myself.

Look forward to the results.

B.M wrote: ↑Thu 03 Nov 2022 10:51pm We have every right to know

We are paying members

Just need to look on the Saint's website under Roughead, gives the ambit of his duties.

That covers the extent of your right to know.

CURLY wrote: ↑Thu 03 Nov 2022 7:45am Interested as to how anyone on here knows what he does and also why do we need to know.

Some SS posters need to know what he does, because at the moment they don't know what to blame him for.

Riewoldt Hayes Norm Smith medalist Goddard Dal Santo Montagna Milne Ball Gardiner Gram 2nd in Norm Smith Voting Steve Baker Koschitzke Dempster And so many AAs in that list . There is absolutely no similarities between our current list and that list, in fact it's embarrassing to even put them next ...

Apparently Corey Enright actually quit Geelong because he disagreed with the change in gameplan, the change that won them the Premiership. Not saying he can't coach, but if true, he got that one wrong. I doubt that as the Cats actually became more attacking after we knocked them off. That mid-seaso...

I love how you continue to make up stuff even if it’s miles from the truth though Not nervous. Just couldn’t be effed And yes…unlike others with no integrity, I stand by that. I won’t want to be on here if Lyon gets the gig (which looks a certainty atm). What’s the point of coming on to a forum and...

Got anything original or are you just going to keep apologising for every mistake and every embarrassing stuff up that the club does? As I’ve written countless times. I will always support my club and my team, no matter what sort of mercenaries get employed by incompetent men. The mercenaries will ...

Got anything original or are you just going to keep apologising for every mistake and every embarrassing stuff up that the club does? As I’ve written countless times. I will always support my club and my team, no matter what sort of mercenaries get employed by incompetent men. The mercenaries will ...

True, some played in premierships with other teams, McEvoy & Steven were very good players, others OK Another way of looking at it, Peake recruited/drafted 47 players, only 11 of whom played over 50 AFL games. Elshaugh brought in 60, 27 of whom have played over 50. Much better strike rate at le...

True, some played in premierships with other teams, McEvoy & Steven were very good players, others OK Another way of looking at it, Peake recruited/drafted 47 players, only 11 of whom played over 50 AFL games. Elshaugh brought in 60, 27 of whom have played over 50. Much better strike rate at le...

The Tweet headline reads "Second Coming" I think I'm gunna throw up Don't worry, Scolops, soon as Rossy loses a couple you'll be able to dust off your RTB archive box and "go to town". My advice? Start a new box with a clean slate, ie no hindsight, perception biases or twisted l...

True, some played in premierships with other teams, McEvoy & Steven were very good players, others OK Another way of looking at it, Peake recruited/drafted 47 players, only 11 of whom played over 50 AFL games. Elshaugh brought in 60, 27 of whom have played over 50. Much better strike rate at le...

John Peake was Recruiting Manager during Lyon's time wasn't he? Elshaug was there, but more a coaching role, took over recruitment after Peake left. (2011?) Peake didn't have many high draft picks as Saints were up the ladder a bit, but his recruiting results were worse the Elshaugs. Well, you are ...

Pelchen made the decisions to trade out existing players for picks Elshaug was responsible for those picks Both fkd the club In Lyon's time, John Beveridge and Tony Elshaug did the job together. Pelchen arrived in 2011. So him and Lyin didn't have long together, though they didn't get on. Reminder ...

May 2021 As is well known, there has always been those within and outside the club who have wanted to get RL back, including ex players of course. What was just a bit of a pipe dream gained a bit of momentum after the Bulldogs smashed us in May 2021 by 100+ points, a few weeks after Tigers smashed u...

https://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/this-is-bulls-why-ross-lyon-really-walked-out-on-st-kilda/news-story/ad7788f2404027ec46424d9945f9e8d7 Lyon’s recent comments explaining why he left the club are now back making headlines with the rift appearing to be mended in extraordinary circumstances. The veter...