Saintsational Fan Forum

scallopsroe

Out coached? Really? To me it came down to resources and ability to perform the game plan They went tall, even with their injuries to talk resources Our tall resources are what they are confirmed by our 2 KPP forwards are Bruce and Membrey, Membrey being 188cm tall In defence we had Carlisle, Brown...

scallopsroe

You’ve got to consider, All of those teams went into the match heavy favourites, and it didn’t surprise that we were outplayed at times during the game. The Freo game and Geelong games were prett6 good efforts imo I was at the Free game, the first quarter was pathetic and expecting to beat them aft...

scallopsroe

If a professional footballer spends 5 days training and preparing and can’t get up for a game, it says something about the player. It’s their job to be up, it’s a non negotiable. Why the inconsistency? You have to consider the impact of the opposition. If they match our intensity around the footy, ...

scallopsroe

Robert Harvey!

scallopsroe

Turbo wrote: ↑Sat 13 Jul 2019 10:20pm Our tackling needs working on. Too many broken tackles. We need to drive through the tackle. Our tackles don't hurt. Wish we had someone that could teach them the basics.
Acres, Sinclair and Gresham really need to take some extra lessons

Sinclair tackling is terrible

scallopsroe

Otiman wrote: ↑Sat 13 Jul 2019 9:34pm Clark and RoMa - great first halves.

Hear Hear!!

scallopsroe

Agree they will head hunt, but the Board is responsible for running a multi million dollar business and not a regional tin shed footy club. CYA is required to show all stakeholders (AFL, current listed players,Saints members, supporters and sponsors) that the right person has been screened and selec...

scallopsroe

saintsRrising wrote: ↑Tue 09 Jul 2019 12:23pm
scallopsroe wrote: ↑Tue 09 Jul 2019 12:06pm The Board must first get coaching applications from interested potential applicants.

Doubt it.

The club will be approaching people. ie Head hunting.

It is not like a candidate can come in from the blue. They know of everyone that would be suitable.

scallopsroe

The Board must first get coaching applications from interested potential applicants. The question is who is available and/or out of contract? Who would have the ability to repair a damaged list, with all its injury issues and a playing list that hasn't been sufficiently disciplined in adhering to on...

scallopsroe

:) A most interesting OP TTT :D For what it's worth, I've been dismayed at the way in which our opponents (not just Norf yesterday) always have players available to take a pass (whether by foot or by hand) Always appear to have time and space, and regularly carve ways through into our defensive fif...

scallopsroe

He (Marshall) needs another tall player to help out around the ground. What we lack is another tall to contest when we frequently bomb the ball out of defence. Note the Lions game, Martin and Oscar had a very good second half, with Marshall under pressure competing with them. We look slow and disorg...

scallopsroe

shrodes wrote: ↑Sun 02 Jun 2019 5:14pm Bye week goodbye week for Richo?

This match is a coach killer, tactically exposed. No excuses, poor team effort.

scallopsroe

I’ll pbly get howled down for this but picking experienced assistants in Watters and Richo hasn’t achieved a great deal for us and demonstrated that experience is not the be all and end all. I want someone with fantastic leadership skills that ppl will follow, is a good communicator, knows what it ...

scallopsroe

Josh Battle was superb and just getting better every game - he's the big plus for me tonight Agree, he has been a stand out this year, the only one of our young guns that is firing consistently. I wonder how he would go up forward, again we scored only 10 goals and badly need some height and footy ...

scallopsroe

This time last year Collingwood had the longest injury list in the comp. They were 9th at 4-3. Many said they lacked depth and few rated them a finals chance. Play the hand you're dealt, find a way. It can be done. If you're good enough to be on an AFL list then you have the ability to perform at t...

scallopsroe

I've been to both interstate games this year.In total the Saints have kicked, in the combined first quarters, 3 goals 2 behinds against our opponents total 11 goals 4 behinds. This is not acceptable and shows that we are uncompetitive away from Melbourne. This has been an underlying theme for some y...

scallopsroe

When Bruce is having a quiet night our forward line are a pack of midgets making it easy for the Crows to clear and rebound. Our clearances and contested ball are shocking. Lift! having a quiet one? He's on one leg. If he was a horse they would put up the screens. We were too short on the forward l...

scallopsroe

When Bruce is having a quiet night our forward line are a pack of midgets making it easy for the Crows to clear and rebound. Our clearances and contested ball are shocking. Lift!

scallopsroe

Grundy is an even bigger asset than Marshall .... and he has been going it alone. Marshall will holler for help when he needs it.... and there are enough players to relieve him so he can take a breather during the game (like Acres, Membrey). We need as many runners as we can muster ... our game has...

scallopsroe

7 clearances. Ben got one. Ceglar got one. Combined they got more than double Ro's hitouts but we won the clearances by plenty and he had a big hand in that. He's an extra mid and is mobile as all heck. Quite seriously I have not seen a ruckman like quite like him. He can handle the body work and i...

scallopsroe

I remember him coming on very late in the 71 Grand Final. Must have been 19th or 20th man. Had a couple of shots at goal, from memory, but the damage was done. RIP I was at the second semi final in 1971 when he ran into an open goal at the western Stand end and missed. Crucial miss at the time, he ...

scallopsroe

I wish Rowan the very best of luck on Sunday. I'll be there cheering on a 15 game veteran against three Hawks ruckmen (Big Boy, Ceglar and Roughhead) with a combined 531 game experience. If we pull this one off and have a win it will go down as one of the Saints greatest victories in recent times. W...

scallopsroe

Reminder to some of the"experts" Pierce has played only 6 games and was a lone ruckman yesterday. This was an unreasonable task for a young ruck, terrible selection decision to have only one ruckman and ask your only tall forward to help out when Big Lewie was taking a spell. The Suns had ...

scallopsroe

I rate him. Plays for the team not individual glory. All great teams have players like Luke. Typical Saints to look at his weaknesses rather than his strengths. I hope we keep him because he has been used incorrectly and undervalued IMHO. If we trade him then it better be with Ratten’s blessing! He...

scallopsroe

Hannebery is useless now, draft a kid instead Also if we replace Richo with Longmire I will be seriously pissed off He's an average coach of a fairly talented team :) The GWS midfield are killing the Swans midfield Hmmmm what to do .... ? Move Franklin to on ball or at least up the ground !! But he...

Search found 111 matches

Re: Ratts Press Conference

Re: Time Will Tell

Re: Time Will Tell

Re: The Coach market

Re: Match/Torch Thread Saints v Cats Round 17 2019

Re: Match/Torch Thread Saints v Cats Round 17 2019

Re: Brad Scott to be announced as Saints coach in August

Re: Brad Scott to be announced as Saints coach in August

Re: Brad Scott to be announced as Saints coach in August

Re: Another perspective?

Re: Rowan Marshall #1 ranked player in AFL since rnd 11

Re: Match thread, Port in Shanghai

Re: Coach in 2020 Who do you think it should be?

Re: Not a bad effort v Eagles

Re: We have the current worst injury list in the AFL

Re: Same forward line entries

Re: Match Thread Saints v Crows Round 6 2019

Re: Match Thread Saints v Crows Round 6 2019

Re: VFL Rd 3 Zebras Vs Seagulls ( Williamstown)

Re: Marshall

Re: Rod Galt RIP

Re: No help for Rowan

Re: Changes for bombers

Re: Dunstan to Blues

Re: The Conundrum of the Hannebery Trade