would free up $800,000 surely that would help
Plus the majority of saints fans would be in favour of seeing them go
Plus it would vut down the media bashing of our club if these 2 players were gone

why don't we throw in Raph or Dawson to sweeten the deal?
Gram & Clarke for pick 22

or

Gram, Dawson & Clarke for pick 22 & 44

Would our chances of winning a flag improve with Fevola?
Would Fevola kick more gaols than Riewoldt?
Would St Kilda benefit if Riewoldt didn’t have the burden of being our main goal kicker?
How much media bashing would we get if things went bad?

I’d put Gram ahead of Ray, Dawson or Raph in our best back 6

Dempster Gwilt Gram
Goddard Fisher Gilbert

no way in hell Raph would ever get all australian

How many best on grounds has Raph had? 0
Gram & Gilbert would have 1/2 dozen each

Pretty clear out of the three who we should keep

I think Raph would turn it over more than Gilbert & Gram combined, if we think he is a mid teir player for our club we're more trouble than we think. When garm & Gilbert are at their best their very close to A grade players, Raph at his best would be C grade, Gram & Gilbert have shown mo...

we can't keep them all, the smart move to get rid of your weakest players while keeping the untried youth.

Public perception is a bitch as most saints fans know

Raph will be delisted as he has no trade weight, we need to free up cash for salary cap & dawson & Ray are yet to resign, do the math, pretty simple.

I think Raph has had his chances at the club and they should now go with youth, if he was to be any good it would've happened by now, Dawson is liability one on one in defence. Ray & Gram at their best are part of our top 23 problem is they are just notconsistant enough if we want to have a seri...

Raph will be delisted, no one wants him, including St Kilda, Ray, Dawson also will be delisted, Ray might get pick up but we will get nothing for him, Dawson career is over plain & simple

no way Malthouse will come to St Kilda, no way

Complete hack that consistently gets beaten 1 on 1, doesn't get enough of the ball himself, cannot kick on his right foot, absolutely no physical presence. He would not get a game by any club that is in the same or worse position than ours – Bombers, Dogs, Dees, Tigers, Crows, North, Swans, Freo. ...

I'd look at Hugh Sandilands, tall, strong, fast, booming kick, good underpressue, would be much better option than Dawson or Clarke down back, has also played on quite a few AFL key forwards throughout the season and held his own.

No chance, no way no how. You can bet on it. Complete rubbish

Good luck finding someone that ticks all those boxes in our current situation. Journo's have it in for us so we'll always have to deal with bad public perception. More important for Saints to get solid sponsorship to get out of financial troubles. Who ever we get we will be bottom half of the ladder...

Brenton Sanderson easily best option

Brenton Sanderson is our best option

No way Malthouse will be at St Kilda, we don't have the funds, resouces or list that is needed to sign him.

Brenton Sanderson, is the ideal candidate

Brenton Sanderson is our best option

Brenton Sanderson is our best option

what if's are a waste of time --- what if Milne had of actually run to the ball or made an effort to try and kick a goal instead of watching it bounce through for a point... how many times has Milne not made an attempt to kick a goal when the ball is 2 metres away from him and 1 metre away from goal...

Cats list much more skillful, mentally tough and Cats have a stronger game plan. I believe their is still a lot of opportunity for our list to improve next year, many players down on form this year, how many A grade players do we have???? Would any of our players be in the top 10 midfieldsers/on bal...

get rid of the 4 of them, all D grade players

He belongs at CHF/Midfield where he can create goals rather than being responsible for kicking them. Riewoldt is obviously way down on confidence and has the burden of carrying the team. His current role is too 1 dimensional. Everyone knows no one can keep up with his running capabilities. Get him f...