Crouch is overrated by most on here. I get that Last year around July most people here thought he was going to cruise to victory in the Trevor Barker Medal. Most of you had him on the podium for the Best and Fairest at years end. Most people on this forum voted him consistently as best on ground for...

D.B.Cooper wrote: ↑Wed 24 Jul 2024 5:31pm

Scollop wrote: ↑Wed 24 Jul 2024 10:53am https://www.zerohanger.com/brad-crouchs ... al-153298/

Geez, Sheil is now an inside bull

An inside bull that enjoys a fair bit of bruise free footy

Short term sugar hits for a spot in finals in 2025 is a short cut that will lead to another drop down the ladder in 2026. We've been there in 2020 and 2023. We need to be patient. Provide opportunities to young players..or... Bring in 23-26 year olds not getting opportunities at Carlton, Sydney, th...

So now the knock on Crouch Who on the St Kilda List is not knocked on this site Simply, you must have watched different games of football than me Crouch was among our most valuable and we trust he returns to that status in the interests of St Kilda improving Also supporting the younger brigade You'...

Would love to see Keeler in this week and/or even Max Heath......both deserve an opportunity The only way we bring in either player is if both Essendon rucks are selected to play again. I don't think they'll play Goldstein Even with both Goldstein and Draper, Marshall can handle ruck duties on his ...

Well, Crouch led our Brownlow votes in 2023 confirming that ... Let me finish that sentence for you if I may. confirming that Brownlow votes have zero affect on match day. Umpires votes are not the be all and end all when it comes to influence on the result of a game. Crouch wasn't a game changer. ...

Jay Clarke is being fed the information by Ross Lyon or someone else close to list management ...just my personal opinion I know it wouldn't be too difficult for Jay to just do some digging, but I think maybe the club want to control the story...and also possibly control/force Crouch to retire… esp...

King Max wrote: ↑Wed 24 Jul 2024 12:39pm

Scollop wrote: ↑Tue 23 Jul 2024 11:01pm

The Fireman wrote: ↑Tue 23 Jul 2024 10:43pm Replacing him will be a battle

Sorry ...but that sort of crap dad joke means you should take a holiday

Lighten up. He was only Joshing.

The 2021 recruits (including our limited draft picks after selling the farm in 2020) were Crouch, Higgins, Chip Frawley, Shaun McKernan, Tom Highmore and Matt Allison St Kilda spent a fair bit of time ...and resources (not to mention giving up 1st and second round picks) trying to find senior player...

The Fireman wrote: ↑Tue 23 Jul 2024 10:43pm Replacing him will be a battle

Sorry ...but that sort of crap dad joke means you should take a holiday

Jay Clarke is being fed the information by Ross Lyon or someone else close to list management ...just my personal opinion I know it wouldn't be too difficult for Jay to just do some digging, but I think maybe the club want to control the story...and also possibly control/force Crouch to retire… espe...

Had another look at that incident today- nothing reportable in it , just two players bumping hard into each other- Stocker was in an awkward position If it was 1994 I'd agree you, however in the current environment it was an action that could have caused a serious concussion or a broken jaw. All th...

Caught a plane to Europe recently and he was on it. My partner got stuck at the passport check in and he walked straight past me. Reeks of “I’m top s***”. Not worth it unless he comes as a FA. Seems like of a lot of interpretation from a brief interaction To also add he had a play boy top on and hi...

BUMP Wood is like a barometer for us. When he performs and has a good day, we normally win. He's a very difficult match up for opposition coaches. He's very good in the air and he's very dangerous near goals. Almost every Saintsational poster in the votes thread had Mason Wood in their votes. Clearl...

Watching him yesterday he absolutely loves playing for the club, but I reckon he and all the players know he's gone at years end. Pretty much a foregone conclusion that JB will move on and that's his prerogative, he's a free agent. To be compensated with Pick 5 in the national draft is adequate com...

Keep pick 4 Beating VFL wet toast don’t mean much Did to me. 8-) It's like beating your kid at ten pin bowling with the gutter guards up. But who would do that? This guy... https://vt.tiktok.com/ZSYWEwHG2/ The first scene shows Benedict Cumberbatch as Vincent in 'Eric'. It's a Netflix series I rece...

I also love Clark. He is contributing and he plays a role, but he’s suffering from a lack of consistency in recent years and obviously…those interruptions from injuries. The real issue of course, is his fitness. He’s not elite in speed or endurance. Too much playstation while he was under Cho. Cho d...

How the hell did Tim Membrey not get 2 x 5’s Bizarre He was clearly BOG Ross initially was going to award Brad Hill best on ground. Lyon scratched out Hill for '5' votes after one of his assistant coaches told him Brad's stats. He'd already given Skunk the 4...so that's where he slotted in Sinclair...

Freo are developing a harder edge too, comes with bigger bodies all over the ground.

https://www.saintsational.net/viewtopic ... 1#p2071611

Define scrawny. You find Tim Tsyzu skinny? Big's good one grab no fumble better. Sincs! Does Tim Tzsuyu wants to come and play midfield for St Kilda. Is he as good as Kozzie Pickett? ...at football? Henry and NWM are scrawny...Sincs certainly isn't . Nas is doing a great job in defence (he wasn't d...

Sincs got the other 5 imo

Tim 5+4
Sincs 5+3
RoMa 4+2
Steele 3+2
Nas 1
Josh 1

I don't get Ross the boss. Why does he want to use scrawny guys in the centre? I understand the speed and agility factor but you've got to win the pill first. His most successful sides have had big strong bulls in the guts who can muscle their way to getting the ball out of congestion He had Goddard...

Agree. In the thread for Top 4 I also tipped Hawthorn to sneak in. I saw who they're playing last 2 rounds

He's going to Collingwood