Personally, I think taking Rory Lobb would be great for St Kilda. It's going to solve 2 issues. Firstly, it'll help RoMa...and secondly it's going to help Max King. At the moment we don't have anyone as experienced or as good as Lobb who can fulfil the role of a forward who is also handy as relief r...

C'mon King Max

That was funny the first time

Now a little stale

What's his best position? Where is he the most damaging to opposition in the modern game? Where do Hawthorn play James Sicily? I'm not equating the young draftee on our books today with the experienced captain we see playing at Hawthorn today, but both have a booming left foot...both are similar siz...

terry smith rules wrote: ↑Sat 15 Jun 2024 12:35am By any team

I think that is a pretty good result for a team who has been pilloried all week

Bump.

The trophy goes to North Melbourne

A horribly miserable cold wet winter awaits that big bunch of Collingwood players who are well into their 30s, They are about to fall off a cliff. Why don't you double down on that bet you took for them not to make the top 8. The odds will be nice and juicy for you Funnily enough, and as you’d expe...

Good plan fugazi

Cordy Jones and Sebby out

NWM, Webster and The Pou in.

Hammer plays as permanent defender and both Pou and Owens play forward.

Both Lobb and English got plenty of the ball. Lobb also had one of his best games ever. Kicked 3 goals and had 11 score involvements. Teddy Richards and other Dogs mids add depth. Richards had 3 goal assists and 12 score involvements. The old firm of Bont, Treloar, and Tom Liberatore schooled the yo...

Dunkley pushed Dow. Josh Dunkley was to blame for the collision Dow had with the umpire.

B.M wrote: ↑Sat 15 Jun 2024 12:45pmYippee

Birthday cake time

The free against Marshall was technically correct because unfortunately RoMa didn't contest. RoMa didn't make an attempt to mark it himself You can't look at your opponent, and make it obvious to the umpire that you're blocking them and then you don't even try to mark it yourself It's not illegal t...

Grow up. Are we incapable of debating this at a constructive and adult level? TBH, It's not a debatable topic here...It's akin to going on a physics forum and putting up the topic of the Earth being flat and asking to debate that. It is a ridiculous post and not warranted here. Ridiculous and not w...

Sainter_Dad wrote: ↑Sat 15 Jun 2024 3:02pm
This adds up to 19 - only 15 to give

You could multiply each individual vote by 15 divided by 19

That's going to be a messy spreadsheet ...you should just ignore all his votes if he doesn't amend them . It's not rocket science

I think Seb, Mason and Hilly were shocking with some of their kicks. But all these guys tried their guts out. Bonner was the bloke who let us down.Not just with the kick for goal but mainly his inability to contest a ground ball. Too timid The 50m penalty against Windhager was the one that was not ...

Our clearance wins didn’t hurt them They walked out there in the end and scored goals so whilst our mids won clearance….the quality was poor and we often turned it over off them by fumbling, over running ball, handballs to players who were hot - that’s all decisions and execution, Little bit of luc...

I think Seb, Mason and Hilly were shocking with some of their kicks. But all these guys tried their guts out. Bonner was the bloke who let us down.Not just with the kick for goal but mainly his inability to contest a ground ball. Too timid The 50m penalty against Windhager was the one that was not u...

The free against Marshall was technically correct because unfortunately RoMa didn't contest. RoMa didn't make an attempt to mark it himself

You can't look at your opponent, and make it obvious to the umpire that you're blocking them and then you don't even try to mark it yourself

Our 2 prong attack was cold and impotent early in the game Theirs was🔥 They also have a weapon who doubles sometimes as their 3rd tall and sometimes he goes into the centre or attends stoppages. Cam Rayner could have kicked 3 or 4 tonight but he was also damaging at centre bounce. Our Cam Rayner is ...

All umpires should be sacked No, John Setka was quite specific. Only the umpires boss. Sacking all the umpires would be bullying. Noticed that you're avoiding posting in the General Forum ace Come on over and we'll talk about Peter Costello and bullying. Too many spuds and shady, corrupt and incomp...

Schoenmaker played very well for a 1st gamer. Battle was very poor so was Cordy. What do you mean. Cordy's two handballs were really good and his one tackle spectacular. The rest of his game, well he took up space on the ground. Would have had better stats if the ball had stopped avoiding him. Mayb...

And we proved we are still losers, thats' our strongpoint. :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: Guys that represented tonight are not losers by any means. Juvenile stuff bobby. +1 Really can't deny that our boys fought it. Some nice passages of play and many positives to take fro...

Maybe it's like a defence mechanism for some. They pretend to distance themselves and laugh at others here for being positive....and they laugh at the club for its lack of success instead of acknowledging the hurt

Otiman wrote: ↑Sat 15 Jun 2024 3:40am Lowest winning score last week, biggest winning score this week.

You've obviously got winning on your mind

That's good

4 Sinclair
3 Henry
2 Higgo
2 Marshall
1 Clark
1 Wilson
1 Wood
1 Schoenmaker

Hard to imagine you don't award a vote to someone who kicked 3 goals, but I just thought he didn't do enough. Owens stiff to miss out on a vote too....as was Dan Butler

It doesn’t bother me to the point that it actually effects my day It is frustrating watching your team play so poorly 7 goals in 120 minutes from 56 entries Unwatchable 7 goals in only 1 quarter tonight That proves we can turn it on. Also shows we don't stop coming. Loved the effort from the team t...