Keen on voting. Must get get Seany the win.

Collingwood is far less entertaining to watch without Dawes.

Dawes to St. Kilda? Thank f*ck the club aren't complete idiots. Dawes in a saints jumper is a scary thought...for St. Kilda supporters.

Will be going for the cats. Yes we threw it away against them, but they play good football and have likable players. I also will be hoping Collingwood make the prelims so I can watch more of Dawes, his shitness is enjoyable to watch.

Saw the first half of yesterdays game at VFL and he was very soft to be honest.

We don't have a vice-captain so who do people think will get the nod. Lenny has some other leadership role so I don't think he will.

Sellar is complete rubbish.

Getting Nathan Brown would have been great for us. He's exactly what we need now.

Tom Simpkin's bumping.

Lenny
Dempster
Armitage
Riewoldt
Very open after that, Milne has only been excellent the last three or four weeks so he's certainly no lock for top 5.

Wasn't able to watch today so could someone fill me in as to how Simpkin, Gram, Jones, Siposs and Fisher played?
Thanks in advance.

I think if we have seen anything throughout his stint on the sidelines, it is that we don't need him to play the sweeper role across half back. The back line has functioned well IMO by backing themselves to kick. I now think we must mainly use him as a mid because our kicking into the forward 50 is ...

I agree that when he was on Brown he did well but I actually thought Gwilt was on Brown for a fair bit last night as well.

A couple of centimetres won't do any harm. Pendlebury is 191cm and you won't find a cleaner player than him.

[quote="saintsRrising"]Simpkin showed how good he is when played in the right position, FB is beyod him.

He takes over from Blake as the "third tall" defender.[/quote]
He played at full back on Ryder for the most part...

Hurley was off at that stage I think so it was a good opportunity to give Gwilt a rest whilst giving Farren a go as well.

[quote="SunburySaint"]Give him the number 8 Guernsey next year absolute quality... Really made our backline look good and very composed[/quote] I'd like him to keep 31. Whilst he isn't dissimilar to Max, I think he should make a name for himself with his own number without the pressure of ...

Was outstanding. Zero goals kicked on him. Did well on all of Hurley, Ryder and Hille at times. Is very courageous like Raph however is calm, makes good decisions and has very good skills.

Membrey not what we need. A quality player no doubt but he's a 186cm medium forward. He has a big body but he isn't tall enough to play key position. From yesterday's players, Tanner Smith would probably be in our sights. Smith is a 194 key back. He is probably the best shut down key defender in the...

The chances of Goddard straight for pick one is zero.

He'd obviously be great for us but contrary to what everyone is saying, he actually isn't exactly what we need. He isn't a stopper of the dominant key forwards, he takes the second tall and works of him to help out Brown or Tarrant. Brown would actually be more suited or us than Reid. We're obviousl...

Got to say I'm not particularly impressed by Watters at the moment. Kosi is barely in our 22 at best let alone when sick so why the hell would he play when we had an emergency who plays the same position.

Simpkin anyone?

Simpkin perhaps?

Far from our worst tonight I thought. Goes out when Gwilt is back but atm not keeping anyone out of the side who desrves it.