Junior wrote:I say stuff Collingwood and let him walk to the PSD.

He goes into the National Draft before the PSD.

Ball will go into the national draft, before the PSD, if a deal isn't arranged.

All class Sainters fans.

Stephen Theodore wrote:thinline wrote:
Stuff him, I say. Mercenary with an overinflated sense of his worth.

xander wrote:Exactly. If collingwood aren't willing to offer us a fair deal we'll deal with other clubs.

Ball isn't interested in going interstate or to Essendon.

saintnick12 wrote:
Ripped apart is ridiculous.

Taylor, his opponent, should have been awarded the Norm Smith. Chapman was the match winner but Taylor was by far the most dominant player in his position over the entire 4 quarters.

Moods wrote:
Really? When was that? Certainly wasn't 2003 b/c he embarassed himself in perfect footy conditions. PLayed OK in 02 GF. When was that again? 7 years ago did I hear you say?

Kicked 3 goals in the 02 GF (3 / 8). Riewoldt got ripped apart by Geelong's 4th best defender.

ace wrote:Not exactly hot for a number 1 pick..

& unlike Riewoldt & the big dud Kosi, Josh has actually stood up in a GF.

Has kicked more goals than any St Kilda player in a GF in 43 yers.

Power Without Glory is as close to a biography about John Wren and the Catholic Church and Collingwood as he could write without being sued. There is 1 chapter about Collingwood in the entire book. It was fiction so unless you were directly involved at the time, your claim "as close to a biogr...

Nicky Winmar didn't feel the need to raise his jumper at any ground other than Victoria Park. Do you think that is just a co-incidence? I love when St. Kilda fans call the racist card. Perhaps you can remind us of what occurred with Peter Everitt & Scot Chisholm. During WW2 and the Vietnam War ...

Whilst most of the other Clubs chose to suspend playing during WW1 so that they could join together with mainstream Australia and fight the War, the 'great Collingwood' showed the rest of the country where their priorities lay - winning Premierships against little opposition. So what about the club...

Young man, if you are going to enter the world of stats, at least make a decent attempt, even if you are making it up. First, you said 'since 04', although including 04 only makes the stats better for the Saints, Next, the Saints played 6 games at the G for 5 wins in 05, 5 games for 3 wins in 06, 2...

perfectionist wrote:Ah, geez! 13 wins and 8 losses or 62%!

04 - 1 win.
05 - 0 wins from 1.
06 - 0 wins from 1.
08 - 1 win from 3.

2 from 6. 33%.

kosifantutti23 wrote: What's Collingwood's record like against St.Kilda in finals since the middle of September in 1966?

1/2.

Your turn.

What is St. Kilda's winning % at the MCG in Finals since 2004?

What's St. Kilda's win/loss record at the G in September since 04?

satchmo wrote:It rained at the G this arvo, so I presume then that the filth didn't train.

Collingwood trained there in the morning before it rained. They were told if it rained (or had done in the 24 hours prior) that they couldn't train there. Same for St. Kilda.

So if it rains at 1pm and training is 2pm and all the players are getting ready at the ground they will be told to pack up and head home. No they will not. St. Kilda would have worked out the logistics of that issue already. Collingwood had to ask for special permission from the MCC to train there ...

plugger66 wrote: Well I dont know about Collingwood but we are training there tomorrow come rain hail or shine.

If it rains, no.

plugger66 wrote:Sorry what does that mean. We are training there.

Not if it rains. The MCC informed Collingwood, that if it rained in the 24 hour period prior, they would have trained at Gosh's. Obviously trainning on a wet surface & with a game to follow the next day, the ground would be chopped up.

plugger66 wrote:We are at the G tomorrow.

Not a chance with the predicted rain.

I suppose, too, you are absolutely devastated that your mob took on Matthews as a coach given his reputation for blatant thuggery... There was quite a lot of debate RE Matthews being appointed as the 2IC at the end of 85'. The Bruns incident was still fresh in the mind & the criminal case that ...

No matter how many times you post this accusation it doesn't make it any truer. Only 2 people for sure know what happened in that incident O'Dea and Greening. I'm assuming you're not either of them so you are either repeating s*** you've been told or are making it up as you go along. There were act...

Do your fellow supporters really need something that happened nearly 40 years ago as motivation to believe your team can get over the line this week, or is there something good about the current team you can highlight? :wink: I don't think the Greening incident is relevant now but you can hardly de...

And this was December 2003... not 1972. You're comparing an off the field incident that was thrown out in the courts of law to a player putting another person in coma, fighting for his life, on a sporting field. What relevance would me bringing up Milne & Montagna being investigated by the Vict...