Jacks Back wrote: ↑Sat 23 Apr 2022 12:28am Out: Hayes (ACL) and Marshall (corked thigh) may need a rest
In: Ryder and Campbell?? (May be a bit slow but we need a second ruck),

Can Sharman come in and maybe Battle is second ruck again?

Ratts said in his presser that Marshall will be right next week . Jones and Ryder will come in .

The lengths people are going to to justify this "dissent" rule is an abomination to the game. It cannot be justified, it will not be appreciated in "D" grade sh!tsville, people are kidding themselves if they think it will. 100% agree the game is fast becoming un watch able.might...

It would be good to hear from our players as to what they think has changed from last year. Its astonishing that since saturday nights embarrassment that our captain or any of our senior players have fronted the media to give any explanation to long suffering members.at the very least accept respons...

Good effort tonight against the tigers CQ you must be proud of the boys.

IluvHarvey wrote: ↑Thu 15 Apr 2021 10:20pm

mickey wrote: ↑Thu 15 Apr 2021 10:09pm For all the McKenzie knockers I'd take effort over skill. We have too many front runners.

I just can’t...

Where is cq saint?
Weak as piss thread going to get a workout this week.

Whether you believe me or not it’s up to you. The players, coaches, administrators,ME, are hurting as much as you- the supporters. I realise from the stands, or the couch it looks as sometimes that don’t give a rats arse but believe me they do. You don’t reach the pinnacle of this sport whether as ...

Im done as well followed and supported this club for a long time but thats it no more .can't take the disapointment anymore

If Geary goes back This would be a mistake. Don't be suprised to see hind if he comes in play hb role . Reason is if his opponent doesn't show some accountability hind is one player who could hurt em with his speed and kicking.would also be easier for him to get into the game instead of trying to p...

I think battle dunny hind / bytel Battle goes forward With Roma full time ruck Gears goes back to cover long Hunter goes back to cover Carlisle Wikie and Howard are good match ups on their tall forwards We bring in dunny and either play extra mid bytel or run hind forward If battle is right he play...

Essendon into Ben Paton.....pricks can f*** off To be fair he plays a position where we have coverage. Paton for Zac Merret or Adam Saad would do the trick :lol: Seriously, would you look at Paton & Dunstan for Zac Merret or Adam Saad? https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2020-trade-thread-pa...

Fair calls. I think that Luke Parker might be at Moorabbin next season. I can’t prove, it’s just a gut feeling. Same with Caldwell. Now you're talking!!! Luke Parker is an absolute gun and at 27 and over 200 games gives St Kilda the experienced midfielder it is chasing. Can't think of anyone better...

Toy Saint wrote: ↑Mon 21 Sep 2020 11:15pm

ace wrote: ↑Mon 21 Sep 2020 11:11pm Looks like we will be playing a pack of Dogs at Adelaide Oval.

That sucks, Saints have earned the right to nominate a home final. Bent over by the AFL again.

I agree but you know what it aint the 1st time we have been screwed by the afl so lets just go there and win and stick it up em .

Shot the lights out for the Giants, this is the year they get cleaned out...Leon's look to the chewing gum left on the top of the coaches box said it all...get it done Gubby are you related to Ian? http://www.globalwaveconference2020.com.au/speaker/ian-mcnicol/ With jones coming back in it gives us...

SuperDuper wrote: ↑Fri 18 Sep 2020 11:53pm Yeah.. who goes out for Zan Jones???

Actually a tough call based on tonight

Yep tough indeed but imo the only one you would leave out is kent nothing personal he was actually good tonight .but i can't see who else you would leave out.

Ape_Man wrote: ↑Fri 18 Sep 2020 10:07pm

skeptic wrote: ↑Fri 18 Sep 2020 9:50pm Said it last week and will say it again... next to Butler, Lonie is the best FP we have. Love his attack on the ball

If Lonie was 5cm taller and 5kg heavier he would be an absolute gun.

Can someone tell wilkie to not just bomb it high to hb please so annoying

Play rounds 1-9 footy, not 10-17. Simple. I disagree. If we play a fast open game, that is just the type of game that gives GWS their best chance of winning, plus also gives them their best chance of getting past our %, plus if not them also increases the odds of the Dees getting past our %. We can...

Kent’s job in the team is to kick goals Dash, run whatever you call it means nothing if you can’t get the ball Taranto,coniglio,kelly,hopper and greene we should've selected another onballer .thats gws strength and our weakness ,got a bad feeling that this is very similar to last week hope im wrong

on the outer wrote: ↑Thu 17 Sep 2020 7:52pm Emergencies are a interesting lot

Marsh, Byrnes, Savage and Dunstan

Any of those emergencies would contribute more than kent .hope he gets a couple of kicks this week

watching and listening to all media outlets over the last couple of days just about all of them have written off gws winning on friday night.bizzare i reckon or do they know something we don't?.

IF HE plays can we run a sweep on when he breaks down? 20minute mark of 1st quarter for me plese! That's a seriously pathetic comment. Do you even call yourself a supporter? This is a bloke that's gone down to Melbourne to rehab a serious hamstring, come back into the quarantine hub and is busting ...

Honestly. The way supporters on here quickly throw the baby out with the bath water never ceases to amaze me. WCE are a team many consider a flag chance. We were a chance of making the eight and are learning on the fly. If we kicked accurately we win. Reset your expectations and you'll find the gam...

Oops yeh
You could probably take your pick for that last spot
Geary,kent,another on baller eg dunstan if he is ready or hanners when he is right to go

Paton howard wilkie
Long carlisle coffield
Hill ross clark
Billings king butler
Membrey marshall lonie
Ryder steele jones
Kent sinclair battle
This is what i'd like to see

Think we're carrying one too many small forward types with Kent, Hind and Butler as they can't rotate through the middle. Butler is a lock. One of the others has to go. Quite a few players yet to get a guernsey this year and we need a point of difference. Savage ok in his one game this year. Parker...

1) Inside 50 entries are horrible, it's long to a contest every time. 2) Midfielders either not being able to find the ball consistently, or blazing away or taking the wrong option when they do get it 3) Forwards not converting when we do manage to carve out a decent chance 4) Every time Melbourne ...