Out: Gilbert (shocking all year), Stanley, Cripps, Gram (past it, just gets it and bombs it and refuses to make a contest), Wilkes (Blake very lucky we have no rucks)

In: Schneider, Gwilt, Fisher, Sipposs, Ledger, Archer maybe for some height

Should be first picked every week, the bloke wins games by himself. The day he retires is the day we lose 50-60 goals a year, most of them freakish, if we are on the way down, let his wizardry give us some joy!!!

Cost us 3 goals directly tonight, must go, play kids and lose rather than HIM making the same poor decisions week after week...

That P r i c k also said on 3AW that Baker deserved his 12 weeks and should have got more...

Milney plays in hardest spot on the ground, people too often judge him on his goal tally, he is a freak that wins us many games... what makes him even better is that every other club supporter hates him with a passion... thats makes him even better!!!!!

What about Milney and Socceroo Scott McDonald

http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/media/images/4 ... d_gall.jpg

About 16 weeks too late, RC dropped, 3 half decent games in 3 years and he couldnt be carried any more. Maybe it is just me, out for first part of year and we were unbeaten, he comes in we start to lose and others start to panic around him... i could highlight at least 2 errors per game that directl...

Would have won by 5 goals, if he doesnt kick them he brings the others into the game as normally has 2-3 flying against the great man...

if we are not 30 - 40 pts better off with Nick then i have never seen him play...

One of the more sensible posts i have read this year... People continue to pump up Raph but he continues to let our team down, he is just not up to AFL standard at its current pace... His lack of Skill, pace, vision and decision making continues to frustrate even the most staunch supporter of his......

Enough Said...

It still hurts big time.

I have not bought a paper for 5 days now (a record)

You should try living ang working in Geelong... It is Hell!!!!

I just dont want to talk to people

Would have been handy in the big one....

We are in the business of winning flags and came up short by a very small margin.

Would have cost us nothing and just may have made the difference

After K. Hunt transfered Codes this week, maybe Blakey should head to the NRL...

How many times can you tackle someone without the Ball????

Go the ball and not the Man...

Cost us 3 goals tonight with scragging that was not needed

Goose = Too Slow

i would take that Deal in a Heartbeat... WHEN we win this year, i dont care if we never won another game EVER!!! I will be in Football Nivarna... I will live in the GG Huggins stand until they rip it down, I will then find a new home where all i will need is a TV and Foxtel IQ to watch it over and o...

ha ha ha you stick up for Raph and bag Milney... You have confirmed your knowledge of Football in the one thread. Milne is in the top 5 most important players at our club. We could never win interstate becuase he couldnt get a kick, now we win because he does, his forward pressure is fantastic and h...

had to take possession and decided to punch it then had to put his body on the line in front of Cox...

we would be better off with 17... what game are you watching.

SPUD

I am sick and tired of reading people stick up for Raph on this website week in and week out, He is a Spud and his 1st half today has bordered on Pathetic... No doubt he will cost us a game one day soon, lets hope it is not a Final. Get rid of him...!!!!!

I would have had him in the votes yesterday...

I laughed when we took him and not Cuz... Now i am really laughing!!!!

Recruit of the year, no question...

How do you go from a Box Hill tryer to AFL gun in 6 months???

Strange World.....

Had nothing to do with the Jumpers, Blake Panicked.... not for the first or last time

we have plenty of avenues to goal, whats Sh*%s me is that sometime we dont kick it Roey or Kosy one out.... back em in I say....

I have always said that is an "I" on his back not a "1" Takes a bounce when should dispose of it and puts the forwards out of position, takes on players when he should dish it off, has shots from 60 when better options up forward, only ever dishes it off once he is tackled or run...

They only struggled early as the Tigers pushed back hard, why wouldnt you kick it to them everytime, they are 2 of the best 5 marks in the game.