CaptainReiwoldt wrote:take away sentiment and BS geelong would take reiwoldt over ABLETT JNR EVERY DAY OF THE WEEK!

people wont admit it but reiwoldt is easily 3rd best right now. Dal Santo top 10. what delivery is dal santo??

Interesting comment. They can win without GAj. Imagine if they had Roo up fwd. SCARY!

I guess the best way to answer is:

If you were starting a team from scratch and had a clear shot at 5 players, who would you get?

I rated him highly from day one, knew we had the right coach back in 2006 when he was appointed, but then again I am a visionary so that is to be expected! It's pleasing to see all the nuff nuffs and GT doll worshippers finally getting a clue and realizing that we now finally have a genuine Real Mc...

Beg to differ, but I reckon Joey is right up there this year. Equal if not more influential than Dal.

That guy sounds like a prick - but not nearly half as bad the Bomber supporters I was surrounded by on L1! LOL. We had 2 goons sitting in front of us. They went nust whenthey kicked the 1st goal. Then called a few players including Kosi(?) when he snapped and misse it a "clown". My mate k...

yes. The "four quarter effort" raised quite a bit of mirth here as well! Why? Despite looking flat compared to the previous 3 weeks, I reckon we were never headed on Sunday, and despite the Dons throwing everything at us, from where I was sitting, I reckoned we did well to absorb the pres...

If he could improve his accuracy and kick 1 or 2 more goals a week, he'd go close to top 3. Many "experts" rated HArvey outside the top 3 because he didn't do damage on the scoreboard like Buckly and Hird. Roo is the same to a degree. If he kicked straighter, he'd be above Franklin with a ...

Well, to all the miserable poo poos: Here's our next upcoming kid.

Go the JG!

The concern for Armitage is that Ross Lyon was crying out for midfield depth, yet he chose to recruit Ray and move Gram and Goodard further up the ground rather than promote Armitage . I think the problem for Armitage is rather that Mini has got his spot, and has pushed past Armo because Mini has b...

The selectors will have the final say. They will be the unfortunate ones to weigh up the game time requirements for goose & max coming into the important part of the season. They are quality players who need quality game time. They could be the difference b/w a flag/not if played/not played. My...

If the comparison is purely player v player, then it's a no brainer. However, Zac has done everything asked of him and has exceeded expectations. Is there room for both? YES. I seem to rcall us doing pretty well with Goose, Max and a certain Penny in 04. And frankly, we've never found a true replace...

Gwilt is doing his job. Could have kicked 2 if he didn't decide to pas it off to Kosi. Uses his body well. Reminds me of Andre the Giant. He has a massive carcass and stands his ground. Goose, God bless him, has to re earn his spot and reputation. He has missed a lot of footy and ouroyr team has evo...

Armo will play when he's earned his chance. Anyway, we have Lenny and Ball who play the same style.

The recruiting of Ray and use of Gram in the middle is to add some leg speed and run through the midfield. Armo doesn't really give you that.

From AFL site.......... Being a one club player was something that the more I thought about, was important to me. I want to stand for something. I am a loyal person and at the end of my career it will be great to look back and know I am a St Kilda person for life. That was something that has heavil...