Who needs a Plan B, when Plan A never fails.

Quality player, deserves one more year at the very least.
And we won't get anything in a trade for him, so we can forget that.

- We have better rucks. (Gardiner & King V Fraser & Brown) - They will struggle to contain our forwards. Presti may be able to shut down Kosi, but who can shut down Roo? And obrien always struggles on Milne. - We can contain their forwards. Blake/Gilbert on Cloke, Dawson/Hudghton on Anthony,...

You could tell he was trying hard to create some play, kick goals etc. unfortunately his disposal wasn't up to it.
But in saying that he is still a gun in and under player who gives his all and should be in the best 22.

How about the fact that the team that finishes fourth has to play the best team and the team that finishes first, only has to play the fourth best team...

Seems pretty obvious to me...

matrixcutter wrote:whats wrong with having a defender on the bench?

Because it cuts our rotation in the midfield.

Look I love Max, but its either him or Zac.

Yeah good on him, I love seeing his confidence grow each week.

All I know is that we can't have both. It's either Zac or Max, and thank god I don't have to decide. But one thing is that we know Max can peform under finals pressure, can Zac? Possibly, but would we want to take that chance.

Like said earlier Gwilt to play a defensive role on Lake.
I'd love to have seen Goose or Lynch, but it was always obvious Gwilt would get the gig and good luck to him.

You have too much time on your hands.

Lynch a chance, but most likely goose.

Would love a PM if possible... Thanks!

For anyone who is watching, is Kosi in trouble?

The problem I see for MacGuire is: a) Will he be as good as he was after that horrific leg break? Look at what happened to Nathan Brown and his career after his leg break. Nathan Brown was heading towards the end of his career after he broke his leg, Maguire is 24/25 so still has plenty of time to ...

He has a massive chance to become our 2nd ruck for the year. Gardiner is clearly our number 1 ruckman and King is a decent 2nd ruck, but nothing spectacular. It was never going to happen this year, because he would not be able to string a good amount of games in the seniors to show some form, but he...

I think he will keep his spot until Dempster gains some form and fitness in the VFL, but unless he improves, Dempster will come in for him.

Yep, Bakes can't go out for Milne, we need someone on their small forwards.

Yeah I was happy with Gwilt today. Lead up well and had a influence, and even got a goal.

Won't lose his spot after that performance, but I'm not 100% sure he can keep it for the whole year.

Yeah it was great.

At Quarter time, I was not worried at all, as I KNEW we would come back.

PM me and i'lll send you a link and password.

In: Aaron Edwards
Out: Jack Ziebell (illness)

Any sites to watch the match online?

If anyone knows one could you please PM me. Thanks!

Another question...

If McEvoy rips it up tonight, will he keep his spot ahead of King. Hmmm...?

Or even if we win, and the whole 'don't change a winning side', meaning McEvoy doesn't get ommited for King.

I was hoping for McEvoy to come in. But does this mean eddy is injured? or that the Saints were just trying to confuse collingwood? :?: geee... Davis and Medhurst out is huge and Anthony and Didak out already. Gonna be tough for the Pies, there is absolutely no excuse if we lose now, yet I'm still n...

McEvoy needs to come in as second ruck, so Kosi can stay forward. Means either eddy or gwilt to go. Before people start saying, why should eddy/gwilt go... blah.. blah... it's not that I don't like them its that for structure its much better we play 2 rucks with Kosi and the forward line and therefo...