This of you who reckon that our favourite son should not be going to Carlton just stop and think... We've had Carlton's favourite son at St Kilda for 2 years now!! Good luck Rob, you've earned the right to do whatever you want to in footy - I hope you enjoy every success at Carlton - just not agains...

mick13 wrote:Crap, one of the best to ever play teaching Carlton's midfield...of Gibbs, Murphy, Judd...

Oh dear. Saints win a flag before these guys really get going...only a matter of time now with Harves on board.

He's going there as DEVELOPMENT coach not midfield coach....

Pffft we can say what we like its a forum...

...and nobody will take any notice if it sheer crap! (like 99% of posts here - including this one...)

We heard the same outcry when Spud went to Collingwood..

If Harves wants to go to another club then all you tossers should respect his decision!

With all those cars around the ground it looks just like a Melbourne suburban or country game and is probably about the same standard!

Dont get too carried away...

Perhaps we should draft Dayne Beams to the Saints - he already has "Strength through Loyalty" tattooed on his chest!

http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/b ... 68868.html

Most people call it a higher number in this regard as generally they are reserved for the 'senior' players... champ. Like the #4 draft pick is a HIGHER pick than #25. Most people??? I've never heard anyone say #4 is higher thn #25. For the sake of this exercise lets call it and "EARLIER" ...

goodie wrote:

Moccha wrote:I'm surprised that u didn't ask what colour undies they wear to the game?

Who said they do?

Ang Christou certainly doesnt... BALL!!!!!!!

I have driven that way recently and the only explosions I saw were some kid letting off firecrackers at Kananook Station. Depends which roads you take :roll: Talk to real estate agents down here..the peninsula is the jewel in Melbournes crown...and it will only shine brighter in years to come 8-) T...

AP Erebus wrote:

Mooksy wrote:A.Hamill - knee - 2 weeks

Lmao..

The eternal 2 weeks

Yeah... a bit like...

S Baker - Knee - 2 Weeks

Lets hope Bakes doesnt do a Hamill!

Jaz wrote:ever since Jason Heatley left we have been woeful in front of goals.

Hmmm... you have a short memory Jaz... Are you saying recently retired coleman medallist and century goalkicker Fraser Gehrig was woeful in front of goal???

I reckon it would be a tough sell for the Council if it planned on selling off any of the Moorabbin Reserve to fund the grandstand removal. You can just hear the residents raising merry hell if the Council tries to sell off any of the land. Who said anything about slling off any of the Moorabbin re...

I have a source at Kingston Council who informs me that $500,000 is only half the estimated cost of demolishing the grandstand. Council are trying to raise the addaitional $ by selling off excess land, so until that happens the grandstand will stay! I reckon it would be a tough sell for the Council...

So... Come om here Topsy Turvey you clown and answer some of the question. Who is going to pay to remove the stands you deem unsafe eh? And how unsafe is it? Come on Topsy....your silence is not appreciated! There's a $500,000 State Government grant for the removal of the grandstands announced a fe...

I'd be interested in what part of Melbourne you are from CS... I hail from the Frankston area and am in FULL SUPPORT of The Saints move to Belvedere. Open your eyes - Narre Warren South. It says so in my details on every post. Congratulations the the decision makers at St Kilda for their vision! Th...

Sorry if you took my comments to think that you were being argumentative. I was just providing some context (and I'm genuinely in awe of you having posted on 1,000+ topics - maybe I just can't type fast enough). If you have followed my posts for a few years, I was very keen to get the Saints to Cas...

Agree BB. Too many people here way over rate some of our players. I would trade amro for a good deal. And he is NOT worth a top 10 pick. I liked danny frawley's idea of trading armo to the hawks at the end of last yr to take their pick and get cyrol rioli. Obviously there is no way armo now compari...

Do not compare Howard with those players Raph had shown potential in the U18 carnival in 2002, where people early rated him a top 3 in 2003 Lenny was a Morrish Medallist BJ was the best Junior in the country and a #1 DP. Brad Howard was a 19yo who had been passed over the year before, he was specul...

Sainter_Boy wrote:M rix L fisher J allen J wall B horward

Bit difficult delisting J Wall when he aint listed in the first place!!

Beno88 wrote:

Adelaide used the pick to draft Darren Pfeiffer who never played a senior game and was delisted at the end of 2007

He has since been picked up by Carlton and played 7 games this year.

Thats right... didnt he kick the winning goal for the Blues against Freo??

I caught the tail-end of something today that mentioned Lowe & Burke (I think) had roped (or had invited) Harvs to play with them???? Apparently Harvs was quite pleased about the invite. Maybe someone could further clarify??? yeah to play for the amateurs Harves has already been approached to p...

We would be better off off-field, I doubt we'd be better off on field.. Precisely. Happy to have a few rogues on the premiership dias next year. I'll drink to that. :p Also, what did Adelaide get from the Watts trade? Adelaide used the pick to draft Darren Pfeiffer who never played a senior game an...

evertonfc wrote:

FortiusQuoFidelius wrote:Didnt we also trade our first round pick in 2002 for Barry Brooks??

I rest my case Your Honour!

Did we use our first round pick on Caydn Beetham in 1999?

I rest my case. FFS

In 1999 we also traded pick #39 for Justin Plapp...

The defence rests but reserves the right to rebuttal.

Personally I reckon you're nuts if you are adamant one way or the other. If there's a ready made player available for a late first round pick - why not do the trade? Yes, but not a "ready made" player with off field issues like Kerr or Didak or Cousins. Recruiting these type of players wi...

fergus watts. only st kilda would do something that dumb. maybe freo. North Melbourne says hi. Very few clubs don't make decisions that in hindsight look stupid. We paid market rates for Watts when we signed him. Unfortunately, unlike you, the club didn't have a crystal ball. You're correct, we don...