Gilbert, in horror form. Isn't enjoying his footy and I doubt he's enjoying life at Seaford or in Melbourne in general. Send him on leave and only bring him back if he really wants to play for the Saints. Given what he's been through, I doubt he will. I think playing for a new club AWAY from Melbou...

Has anybody else noted the fact that the top two teams this year have their own reserves team and arent affiliated with a VFL club? Is the benefit of developing and playing kids in the position you want rather than where the affiliated club wants paying dividends to Collingwood and Geelong? Should ...

Con Gorozidis wrote:

Johnny Member wrote:

Con Gorozidis wrote: Start looking at a trading strategy

Not sure how it's going to be possible, but we simply need some gun young players to arrive on the doorstep of the club.

I still cant quite get my head around how the Pies landed Jolly and Ball when they were already top 4.

It's called DRAFT TAMPERING!!

Has anybody else noted the fact that the top two teams this year have their own reserves team and arent affiliated with a VFL club? Is the benefit of developing and playing kids in the position you want rather than where the affiliated club wants paying dividends to Collingwood and Geelong? Should w...

To the supporters who walked out on mass at the 15 minute mark of the last quarter you are a disgrace. Was about 50% of our bay who left, bay 15/16. I am also sick of going to the footy every week and hearing people who are wearing our colors and constantly complain and bag St Kilda. Our effort is ...

elvis lives wrote:To think plugger66 works so hard to be the biggest wanker onthiss site and you go and gazump him with one post, doesn't seem fair really

Dammit... you're onto me!!

SainterK wrote:
It was 1st playing 10th for a reason.

for many reasons actually... one of them being Lyons poor coaching!!!

To the supporters who walked out on mass at the 15 minute mark of the last quarter you are a disgrace. Was about 50% of our bay who left, bay 15/16. I am also sick of going to the footy every week and hearing people who are wearing our colors and constantly complain and bag St Kilda. Our effort is ...

clarky449 wrote:Should have other things to worry about in your life then spelling on an internet forum/

Just trying to give the players a break by taking the focus away from the team's poor performance and onto the supporters' poor performance!

Na guys. I made this comment last season or so, and everyone called me out on it. Oh, he's taken us to grand finals in 2 years. Just remember that. He's a top coach. Never made a mistake. Ever. Indeed you did... in fact he is well and truly living up to your description of him as a "One Trick ...

Any news as to why he was left out of tonight's team? There wasn't even an announcement made about his withdrawl :? Hopefully nothing too serious, like a case of frustrated-playeritis. That could take a good season for him to get over. They didnt mention on the TV that he had pulled out but he must...

SaintWal wrote:Your on too something!

Sorry.. I forgot Your and You're & to, two and too...

lennyeverywhere wrote:To the supporters who walked out on mass at the 15 minute mark of the last quarter you are a disgrace.

FFS... they were only copying the coach who also walked out well before the game finished.

Is the coach a disgrace too??

Sorry... bit of a leading question there...

If t lynch doesnt offer a bit more than either of those muppets then I will go he for tiggy. Reputations/record only get you so far, we are 12/13 games in and both have been woeful, consistently. Surely it's time to give lynch and or walsh a go. Surely? On what basis do gram and Gilbert continue to...

When are some of you halfwits going to learn proper grammar and language skills? When I read the incorrect use of there, their and they're or see could of, would of & should of instead of could have, would have & should have I sometimes feel I'm reading a Collingwood forum rather than a St K...

This runner should be replaced immediatly. :x He is a repeat offender :shock: and possibly cost us the game as he changed the momentum early in the game. He also runs around like a headless chook and even after giving away a free and a certain goal nearly got involved in the game 15 mins later. :ev...

saintpeter wrote:Gamble..did better that Roo as a forward...fact

+1

How about something like this. Gilbert to GWS Taylor Walker to st kilda Top 15 pick to Adelaide I consider this to be a win for everyone. I would also target McIntosh from north Melbourne. That way we could have McEvoy, walker and Roo all rotate, through the forward line. Close... Given that Walker...

Who really cares about Gilbert...? He's off to GWS next year and I say good riddance! He has caused this club far too more trouble than he's worth.

Siposs does not deserve to be dropped nor will he be... his job was to keep Maxwell away from the play... to do this he, of course, is away from the play too, so you cant expect big numbers from him. He did his job, he will stay!

After leaving the Saints in 1980, Russell Greene played in Hawthorn's 1988 premiership win in what was his last game for the Hawks. I'm pretty sure he played in both the 1983 and 1986 premiership teams before that as well. Indeed I had forgotten about the Hawks previous wins. In fact Russell Greene...

Dr Spaceman wrote:

White Winmar wrote:Stop it. This is getting depressing!

We could balance it out with a thread about players who left St Kilda and played in a wooden spoon team

Dont think there are many players to have left St Kilda to play at St Kilda...

After leaving the Saints in 1980, Russell Greene played in Hawthorn's 1988 premiership win in what was his last game for the Hawks. I'm pretty sure he played in both the 1983 and 1986 premiership teams before that as well. Indeed I had forgotten about the Hawks previous wins. In fact Russell Greene...

Stillwaiting wrote:What about Val Perovic, would have played in a carlscum flag, and Ruseel Greene at Hawks

Perovic would have played in 2 - 1981 & 1982

bergsone wrote:Not sure but S.Rae play for tigers in a flag year?

Correct - 1973