Why?!

I admire the bloke, YES. But do I quivvle as though my world is lost, NO.

Perspective people. Honestly

get over it.

He's a player. A good player. But stop making me sick with all this sentiment.

Congratulations on a great career....but to say that you are shattered and broke down crying as though your mum had died, pllleeeaaaassseee?!?!

Retraction?! 1 game isnt going to change my mind. I have fortitude and belief in my theories.

Fair call Wanyne. I agree 100%.

nds?

Just thinking (which may become relevant in the last day of Sept), if you were asked to compile a full side made up of players from either SKFC or GFC, how many of our players would you have in the side?

You highlight my point exactly!! These people you say have urged Bangers to 'play on' next year are falling into the same 'sentiment' hole as a majority of other supporters at our club. Do you honestly believe that it would be beneficial to the on field performance of the StKilda FC if Harves was to...

Go on, ban me. Pathetic.

I thought this was a "DISCUSSION" forum.

I have not been rude, or derogatory in any way.

That is why I have chosen to read this forum for so long and not actually post.

[quote="joffaboy"]F*** off troll.[/quote] Cop out. If you disagree, explain 'why' you disagree rather than dribbling that cr@p. Last time I checked I thought this was a 'Forum' where different ideas/opinions were discussed/debated rather than everyone slapping eachother on the back and jus...

[quote="TimeToShineFellas"][quote="BallyIsBest"]If he gets a heavy knock, he is basically out of the game. [/quote] Ever been on the receiving end of a bump from Josh Hunt? Tipping even a younger body would take a long time to recover from a bump that was given out like that. It ...

Well, I am not in my lonesome with my theory....

Grant Thomas on SEN this arvo reaffirmed my sentiments.

Krispy Kreme's?

Its always popcorn time for the cheer squad.

stinger, after reading your last ridiculous post re: Scarlett, you are the reason why we come across as one of the most hated teams in the AFL.

Pull your head in or I will do it for you.

stinger, whats your point??

But you highlight the crux of my whole argument.... you may have been to every Sainters game for the last 45 years, but how many premierships have you seen??????????????

Now is the time for change. NOW. "For the greater good, tough decisions must be made"

Saint1974, p!ssing people off is not my intention. Just putting my point of view across backed by logical reasoning (IMO).

PS. I guarantee that I have been to more games than you....but lets not turn this into a p!ssing contest.

If Harves is dropped and we win next week, isnt that the point proven that he is not needed in the side? And, as for the '21 years of service' comment....I think it was 1 too many. Once again my point of rewarding mediocrity. And Freo, at least they have the courage to clear out their dead wood...i....

Life Long Saint .... you are pathetic. You dont even warrant further acknowledgement. As for the last post, I am not suggesting to drop everyone who had a bad game. What I AM suggesting is: Harves should be given a 'rest' this week as he is a liability due to his ageing body. If he gets a heavy knoc...

[quote="Life Long Saint"]BallyIsBest = Matthew Scarlett!

Congrats on learning how to type, Matty![/quote]

Pathetic. Moron.[/quote]

If you actually READ what I have written rather than accusing me of having alterior motives (the easy option as you dont agree *debate is healthy*), I'm sure you would see that I would not waste my tiome writing rubbish that I did not believe in.

Each to his own.

[quote="Saint05"]

Will never forget Round 7, 05... I think thats why i have no respect or time for that dirty team ever since[/quote]

What happened?

SORRY, SainterDad and Saint Mik, I forgot you're only truely a saints supporter the moment you post on this forum. Forget about first match attended, first membership purchased, its all about the date you joined up here. How many of you went over to Perth this year to watch the saints play, TWICE? I...

Talk about being shot down?! I'm not surprised with the responses, all through history geniuses are often ridiculed because their thinking is against the grain, rather than the sheep mentality of the rest of you. YES, we all agree/know Harvey WAS a great player and will go down as one of the VFL/AFL...

Hate to be 'negative', but a massive opportunity was lost this weekend. Had we of won, it would have been likely that Hawthorn and Geelong play eachother in a Prelim knocking one of the two 'fancied' teams out. And would have easily been able to account for Sydney/ Bullies IMHO in the other Prelim. ...