Doesn't it sounds ridiculous though?? Kerr for Dal Santo. A few years back you'd have given 2 Kerrs for one Dal Santo. It's a bloody joke! :( Maybe we pay these blokes too much?? The Cats have taken pay cuts and are setting the field on fire. Begs the question. no way. dal was good. but kerr was al...

He shouldn't be overrated....I think he is still being judged on '04/'05 and his potential. He may have been crook but he is out there now and doesn't work anywhere hard enough for the team. As mentioned earlier he is happy to cruise. Watched him on Sunday - at one stage stands 5-10 metres off a man...

He is far to slow now. Simple. No other reason and I am supported by the last 2 coaches. and playing him in the ruck supports that issue??? 6 hit outs to Goddards 2??? Yeah righto, don't go out a limb here :roll: So he is not "far too slow" to play forward??? Not far too slow to play ruck...

Nothing wrong with the forward structure - its the delivery that was the main problem today. Secondarily some of the individuals had an off day...... Exactly what I was going to type.... But.... Charlie Gardiner is too slow in both by foot and mind to play up the half forward... If played his best ...

Well there wasn't too much right with the fwd structure if we only kicked 8 gls from only 8 less entries into the fwd 50! it came in under extreme pressure, but you have a point. perhaps allen in next week? Totally agree, but I think the forwards had no room to move so the mids had to pinpoint thei...

Nothing wrong with the forward structure - its the delivery that was the main problem today. Secondarily some of the individuals had an off day...... Exactly what I was going to type.... But.... Charlie Gardiner is too slow in both by foot and mind to play up the half forward... If played his best ...

FFS BIRSS HAS TO BE GIVEN A GO!! Eddy out - Birss in IF Ball is ok C Gardiner out - (also depends on Blake) Im yet to see C Gardiner back up an appearance with a good game. Correct - Eddy, 2nd to the football & no iniative when he had it. Birss has more composure and hurts more offensively than...

Kosi - Woeful. One of his very wost games. His decision making was deplorable in disposal and in making position for his team mayes Kosi is NOT a ruckman.... time is now for the Saints to realise this.... 6 hit outs, now that's just 4 more than Goddard .... Time for the Saints to find a spot that h...

Gwilt or Gehrig or Ferguson or Allen then? Personally, even though it is impossible most likely I would like to see Fraser play when we make it through to the last day in September. Even if its just for the purpose of running over people it may make a few Cat defenders think twice about where he is...

If only all our players showsd the committment of CJ...
NDS is uncommitted to the team cause!