saynta wrote: ↑Tue 18 Jun 2024 9:56pm

mr six o'clock wrote: ↑Tue 18 Jun 2024 9:26pm The biggest problem for the AFL is that these poor decisions are now happening multiple times a week highlighting how bad the umpiring has become.

Correct, and well pointed out.

Even more so is that with 4 Umpires you can get 4 interpretations of an event within the same game!!!!!!

74 Sinclair
63 Marshall
62 Higgins
14 Wood
13 Henry
12 Owens
11 Windhager
8 Schoenmaker
5 Clark
3 King
3 Wilkie
2 Wilson

Therefore:
5 Sinclair
4 Marshall
3 Higgins
2 Wood
1 Henry

WellardSaint wrote: ↑Sun 16 Jun 2024 9:33am Owens got tripped.

I heard ump say 'reported'

Nothing from AFL

Wellard - he said - 'Minus the Report'

SaintWiki wrote: ↑Sat 15 Jun 2024 9:54am 3. Marshall / Sinclair / Windy
2. Higgo / Owen / Henry
1. Clark/ Wood / Max / Butler

Shoeny great start

This adds up to 19 - only 15 to give

My issue with the constant posting about umpires is that there is no recognition that they might make a mistake as humans. It is always ‘blatant cheating’. I don’t agree with every decision made, but I recognize that we also get calls in our favor that may be wrong. Curly seems incapable of either ...

My issue with the constant posting about umpires is that there is no recognition that they might make a mistake as humans. It is always ‘blatant cheating’. I don’t agree with every decision made, but I recognize that we also get calls in our favor that may be wrong. Curly seems incapable of either ...

Devilhead wrote: ↑Fri 14 Jun 2024 11:04pm Ah Chee throws ball back to Butler ... no 50 .... but Higgo kicks it anyway

Butler called for it - in earshot of the Umpire

The Fireman wrote: ↑Fri 14 Jun 2024 10:47pm Dud and curly. 3 week ban. Gameday threads

At least next weekends Game Day Thread.

Free kick Goal square infringement Never ever heard or seen such a thing. It’s almost as if you don’t know the rules :lol: What was it for then and explain to all the commentators It was a goal square infringement - ie part of the 6-6-6. One player MUST be in the goal square - not sure that their p...

mr six o'clock wrote: ↑Wed 12 Jun 2024 10:06pm The only discount I want is from
8675309 !

One company tried bouncing their Millennial employees with a phishing email - the only hint was the identifying detail was 8675309 - no-one got the reference.

Do we get a discount at 3608 Distillery as they are a Partner?

https://www.3608distillery.com.au/

saintsRrising wrote: ↑Wed 12 Jun 2024 7:40pm

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Wed 12 Jun 2024 7:29pm Hopefully gets 20 possessions.

Well there is now un upside if we kick a truckload of behinds.......we get to watch Arie take more kick-ins

Ummm - No - Brisbane to kick a lot of points - Arie to hit the middle - midfielders to storm forward - and kick it deep into the pockets

79 Sinclair
60.5 Battle
57 Wanganeen-Milera
36 Windhager
17 Wilkie
15 Marshall
14 Steele
11 Clark
7.5 Butler
2 Dow
1 Higgins

Therefore:
5 Sinclair
4 Battle
3 Wanganeen-Milera
2 Windhager
1 Wilkie

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Mon 10 Jun 2024 8:54pm

Sainter_Dad wrote: ↑Mon 10 Jun 2024 8:49pm

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Mon 10 Jun 2024 11:07am It looked like Andrew had his arms around King. Who started it?

Mac Andrew - but that does not matter - who started the push and shove that got Butler a shot on goal? Think it may have been Butler.

But Butler got it in the throat.

LOL - and then Butler got it through the big sticks!

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Mon 10 Jun 2024 11:07am It looked like Andrew had his arms around King. Who started it?

Mac Andrew - but that does not matter - who started the push and shove that got Butler a shot on goal? Think it may have been Butler.

Hack wrote: ↑Mon 10 Jun 2024 8:39pm Commentators these days are a disgrace and need to pull their heads in

They have an AFL driven Agenda

And we are but a footnote.

So, not noticing King at that time, I would assume that the GC defender was endeavouring to keep King in such a position that the GC defender could peel off to impact (either of) Henry or Higgins And King was trying to lead him away hence the GC defender impeding King’s movement by holding him In t...

Devilhead wrote: ↑Mon 10 Jun 2024 8:18pm Gawn got 1 free today and got mauled all day in the ruck contest

Maybe the umpires have been told to ignore holding infringements

I blame Max King

I blame Ross and the move to Seaford

Devilhead wrote: ↑Mon 10 Jun 2024 8:18pm Gawn got 1 free today and got mauled all day in the ruck contest

Maybe the umpires have been told to ignore holding infringements

I blame Max King

I blame Ross

And in that pic, look at the St Kilda number 1, the ball at the time in the hands of Henry who was free, having received the ball from Membrey who received it from Clark As far as I could make out (because my focus was on Henry and Higgins - so not King) the whistle went when Henry had uncontested ...

Due to Is what you actually said Don’t back track, just say you didn’t mean it and meant to say Maybe it’s contributed You are actually arguing but not stating the factual commentary Lucky I don’t use the quote button eh?! Then you make some personal insults because you know what you said. I have e...

CURLY wrote: ↑Mon 10 Jun 2024 7:53pm

Scollop wrote: ↑Mon 10 Jun 2024 7:27pm Wow wee boy oh boy

CURLY is now making up stats (or putting on some extra mayo) to hang it on umpires

Give it a rest

Go check the stats

Curly - Max Gawn got 8 frees - we got 10 for the game.

Due to Dear yeah?! 👍 I don't know - you are banging your head against the keyboard and hoping it makes sense For Clarity You introduced Dear and said Hawks had found one here I agreed saying he will be fantastic - and said that having a 2nd marking target may be a reason for Hawthorns revival in th...

There has been two power forwards since as long as footy has been played Lockett and Loewe Brereton and Dunstall Carey and Longmire Kennedy and Darling Brown and Lynch We have 24yo 202cm stick insect And 20yo 196cm under developed Caminiti Membrey is probably done OFFS - This was my point regarding...