So casey-Melb Sandy -saints Frankston-Frankston,we are moving to frankston ,but playing with sandyAlignments with vfl clubs are getting more confusing all the time.Hope we can keep the scorps coach in some way but

What was his inj history at carlton like?

bigcarl wrote:big carl ditterich was my hero as a kid. had a guersey with 10 on it. he was the most fearsome footballer around in the late '60s.

My fav too,bugger you you beat me to it

Agree to disagree with you magic,maybe i played in a different era Head over the ball fair enough report I will take back the soft in some instants but when you say choose to bump,its an instinct to bump taught as kids.Was T West reported?way too inconstant for my liking ,but do you agree they alway...

So we take the bump out completely,fail to see how Murphy deliberatelytried to hurt the other player,IMO free kick and get on with it,was their a free kick paid?Was he reported at the time?IMO Soft

At least we now have a player who showed a climpse of form on the forward line,something we all have been searching for,last week we were searching for a name to put in ,now we are talking on how to use him better,improve his game etc .Light at the end of the tunnel? lets hope so

Wonder if it was a saint who laid that bump what some on here would be saying now SOFT decision ,made by SOFT people who are trying to make it a SOFT game.fair dinkum dont watch slow motion replays if you do ,your kidding yourself

saintsRrising wrote:

Enrico_Misso wrote:He left to coach in the country.

Apparently they offered him more money than Geelong

Back in the 30's would Geelong have not been "in the country" too????

Still are arent they?

Unpopular coach winning a flag ,even i wouldnt mind seeing that.

bigcarl wrote:

saintsRrising wrote:GT came out and endorsed RL for the job just after his appointment

i always put that down as an attempt by a shattered man to be gracious after having his guts torn out.

I reckon thats the impression i got too

Washe sacked ?

Disposal has been the problem ,as we all know,but against melb it was allright.improving which we all want .See how this holds up against better sides under more pressure.certainly have him in my 22 ,especially if the skills KEEP improving

good for us this week ,but i dont reckon he should be rubbed out for that

Your a JINX Follow Geelong or someone.

Dont reckon X is a GUN player but could be a very good player for us .Do like the balsa wood comparison though.Interesting to see where we all rate him after a long inj free run

Our best win for the year so far?

R Harvey not amongst our best players,although another serviceable game from the champ,i for one am more than happy to see the names like Jones Armo etc being spoken about instead of the great man.Was he inj ?dont know .Sure he will be in the heat of it next week,but in some ways its nice not to see...

Looks to me like a man who knows that he has to produce now, or hes career is over,improving all the time after missing o lot of footy.Upside for me is that he seems to have done the hard yards to achieve this .Having said that i have never rated White [melb] highly,but do look forward to seeing him...

Next 2 weeks will tell,either we are back in the race, or not.Yesterday was a step in the right direction.Lets face it the Dees are terrible,but you can only play against who they put on the field,and lets face it they apply any pressure at all.That will be completly different next week

Who said Dempster kept a good player quiet? Who was the good player? Wonaeamirri? He's played a handfull of games and was all at sea today. Dempster did nothing but kick a 65 metre goal when the stupid Demons let him run unchallenged through the middle of the ground with 5 seconds left. Drop him. B...

Seems strange how his body can change from 1 week to the next ,anyway looked a lot better

Looked to me to be a Robbo melb type forward ,clearly jumped in front of charlie today,and gave our forwardv line flexability .But the goal kicking ?

Need to practise the way golfers put..... 10 shots from 20M....any miss, back to zero same from 30M, From 40M then at 45 degrees.....both sides.... do it at the end of training, so the pressure is on to finish, or they will be there for hours......either way it is repetitive training..mental and ph...

The more clash strips i see ,the worse they are looking,maybe time to go back to all original strips ?

Definately a forward,