Cotchin missed 4 weeks from the same injury last year

Well if peris is a mile off, caminiti was 1000 miles off in January, given he wasn’t training with an afl club or on a list…

So you never know….

Freo defensive possessions had little to do with Cordys game impact. They kicked it to themselves.
Freo’s failure to move the ball and score was probably a more relevant observation.

Byrnes is exactly the type of player Lyon will get the most out of.
Now onto dougal

The Taberner free was not there, Wilkie was held at the same time just as much. Having paid that free, it should have been advantage and a goal to Fyfe. How many errors in one passage does a umpire want to make. It’s ok to pay the Clark insufficient intent, but why did the initial decision of throw ...

Meniscus arthroscope can be played on within 3 weeks

25 years on and I still can’t forgive alves

Vortex wrote: ↑Tue 24 Jan 2023 6:39pm

maverick wrote: ↑Tue 24 Jan 2023 6:08pm Not sure he deserved another crack, but good luck to him all the same

It's a sign of how shallow the talent pool is across the AFL, Brisbane are desperate with a massive hole left my Adams.

Yep fair enough

You are allowed that opinion maverick but a poster has debunked (offered another opinion) the myth that Clark is not working hard enough. Have you seen him skipping sessions, not reaching his targets as set by the fitness staff? Why is he an A grader? Is that your expectation? Can he be a B grader ...

Of course he should be an A grader, it was a good draft. He’s barely a B grader, would he even be in our top 10 -12 picked? If he’s hitting his fitness goals there may lie the issue, we recruited him to be a mid, he’s not. We are desperate for A grade midfield talent, we need him to deliver beyond b...

Not sure he deserved another crack, but good luck to him all the same

This thread is hilarious. The bloke is not fit enough He has not reached his potential at all Yes he has had collision injuries, yes he is courageous. Just because you question his work ethic, doesn’t mean you question his ability. He should be an a grader and he’s not, and he’s not because I don’t ...

Rays biggest issue is that he kicked floaters
Long kick but took too long to get there

Joyce was a complete liability every time he played afl

Can’t see Webster getting a game personally - we have moved passed him I think

Paton-Howard-Battle
Clark-Wilkie-NWM (or Sinclair if not midfield)

And then you have Coffield and Highmore as well.
Think Webster is 8th in line for a back 6 spot

Cordy will not be playing seniors surely

I think Howard is one player Lyon will help a lot. Look for him to be a big improver next year.

From what I have read and seen

Mackenzie is very good at most things but not elite.
He has shot in the draft boards in a week draft.

As others have said Phillipou and Humphrey are riskier but have elite attributes.

Reckon Humphrey will be gone by our pick.

B.M wrote: ↑Tue 25 Oct 2022 11:51pm Curious

What year did you expect Richardson to make finals?

Every year

Really.
Do we have to post the past again and again
I thought coaches don’t matter, why do you care

I cannot believe how much people undervalue Bowes, he is a good player with strong skills ready to break out imo
I think he is a mid as well

Of course they haven’t because we haven’t
You can’t get closer than a draw, but hey…
Stanley might get dropped yet

And we have club captains in Hamill and Steele
Vice captain in membrey
Coleman medalist in Gehrig
Nearly norm Smith medalist gram
Excellent players in Dempster and Schneider and voss

Etc etc

Every club has them come in and go out
We only focus on one way

No top 10 pick - he doesn’t leave
Simple
Hold him to the contract

Clark is not a good ball user, he should be and can be, but he is not.
He turns the ball over too much, both by possession and getting caught in possession.
Yes he has had injuries but he should have improved more by now.
Is that st kildas development capabilities or is it him?
I wonder