Buchanan got one, this surely is a joke.....

Gilbert is capable of playing full-back after a pre-season ... he is 194cm. Chips also destroyed Hansen ... pantsed him. Disagree that he can't play fullback. Goose struggled ... but one of Lynch's goals was from a mark that shouldn't have been paid, and another was from a flukey snap. Wasn't as ba...

saint66au wrote:

The Lights are from Holland

LOL..Where else would you buy lights that help grow grass better????

Of course Baker is going to admit he had contact with Farmer!! Farmer ran into him!! That's not the point, the point made by Lewis is that because there was no evidence as to how the contact was made Baker should have just said that the contact was purely accidental and not made because he delibera...

Understand both your points, but the system hasn't changed over the years, we should have used it and he would be free right now, simple as that.

Very good thread. Completely agree, he can't have a 25% reduction because it went straight to the tribunal, hardly ethical. Why does Kosi have a duty of awareness but Farmer doesn't? Quite right above in the Hall case, they were in the next movement of play, so to speak... I just find this unbelieva...

Solar wrote:the reporter on SEN has said that from his view the saints did EVERYTHING they could, they all thought he would get off.

The result is everything, its a fail whichever way you look at it

We must have the prosecutors in the OJ Simpson case, every time we complain about our QC's, I remember Hamill getting a week for tripping because we got the leg wrong!!!

This is shameful, unfortunately Kenny S, this is your area of responsiblity, fix it...

Get real, of course we appeal.
Take out an injunction ala the Dunkley '96 GF case so he plays this week at least.

This tribunal wheel of fortune really found a good one here

Dal is as accountable as Banger, care to criticise the great man as well?
How accountable do you think Judd, Cousins and Kerr are?

IMO he has already been delisted......M.Clarke, was back from injury and straight in, of Baz who was playing better....so obviously Baz has no future...as I said, disappointing.....the games where he did not ruck much....Mathhew Clarke and Michael Rix played in....barring those three, he has been t...

Marto, in your opinion, can he still make it or is he gone?
I mean Rix didn't play his first game of AFL until he was 25....

While you can get ALL players to play harder, tackle more etc....some players are just naturally pre-disposed to being mean bas****. Baker was not taught to be mean & fierce....nor was Sammy... and no matter how much you coach you will NEVER turn players such as Harvey, Dal or Fiora into mean b...

Carn_Sainter - we have a list full of players that can take physical punishment, which makes them courageous and tough, absolutely no doubt. We have one, maybe two players that initiate the contact, this is a far different attribute. This I think is difficult to teach. We need a few mongrels, player...

You all make good points on the loss, and I agree with most of them, to some extent at least, but I reckon every half decent team that plays Sydney think they cost themselves the game. Everyone constantly underestimates them, and makes it look like they themselves are the reason for the defeat. In t...

I reckon most people's ladder predictors had this as a loss, but we think this loss means we are worse than last year for example. Maybe it was because it was a shocker of a game, not sure but I think we under estimate the Swans a bit. The Swans will win every game from here and finish top 4 and mak...

I really do find it amazing how every problem with the team is attributed to our former coach. Under GT we were one of the best tackling teams in the cop. At least top 5 and we usually had one or twp players in the top 5 for tackles in the league. We got respect as a team because of how we attacked...

The naturally brilliant footballers on our list, all two of them, will be 1 & 2 in the B&F this year and maybe both AA. Hardly all at sea. How many times do you want to write the same thing? Wouldn't be too many on here "sucked in" by you that's for sure... If you can find one sin...

The naturally brilliant footballers on our list, all two of them, will be 1 & 2 in the B&F this year and maybe both AA. Hardly all at sea.

How many times do you want to write the same thing?

Wouldn't be too many on here "sucked in" by you that's for sure...

Chips HBF
Riewoldt HFF
Dal W

for mine

would love Harvs to sneak in