Why do so many instantly play the victim card as soon as some criticism is pointed our way? We're 15th!!! The competition is as even as I can remember Last year was similar to this year in that after Rd 16 ... 15 sides had % above 92 We have played 15 games and have lost 6 games under 10pts and won...

Looks like we might be able to get one of them.
Or two?

4 sinclair
4 marshall
3 wilkie
2 wanganeen milera
2 wood

This adds up to 19 - only 15 to give You could multiply each individual vote by 15 divided by 19 That's going to be a messy spreadsheet ...you should just ignore all his votes if he doesn't amend them . It's not rocket science :mrgreen: Or just take his top six. (They add up to 15) It's a little an...

That gets one monkey off our back.

Now lets go ahead and win some games.

4 Marshall
4 Sinclair
3 Higgins
3 Wood
1 Wilkie

3 Wood
3 Wilkie
3 Sinclair
2 Windhager
2 Hill
2 Steele

Great looking team!

Only Crouch, Stocker, maybe Hayes missing from best 23.
If we play to our strengths we should absolutely steamroll this 3rd bottom rung side.

4 NWM
4 Steele
3 King
2 Sinclair
2 Higgins

Henry looked sluggish and uninterested all day.
We've already seen he can be dazzling and dynamic, and that he loves being with us.
What's happened with him?

5 Marshall
3 Hill
3 Sinclair
2 NWM
1 Wilkie
1 Owens

I thought it was a plausible and interesting analysis.
We've certainly lost the spark.
Maybe we need to just fanatically go for goals, even if the opposition kicks more. Fake it till we make it.
It's been save it till you lose it this season.

Marshall
Wilkie
Steele
Bonner
Battle

Love him and believe in the Pou, but 1 kick, 4 (mainly ineffective) handballs, 0 marks, 0 tackles says being gifted a game each week may not be the best strategy for developing him.
Garcia, who is far less equipped to be a dominant forward, at least made 7 tackles in the same forward line.

I am a very keen King fan.
But today was a very poor and worrying effort.

Sinclair,
Wilson,
NWM
Battle
Hill

plus many more very good games just out of the votes

The fact is that in the 12 months ending June 30 last year, 70% of all murder victims in Australia were male. And that percentage is consistent over many years, so why is it that only female victims are newsworthy? Approximately 33% of all victims of domestic violence are male, why are we only inter...

I'm sick of the tokenism of gender equality. That's what happens when you put a woman in charge of a man's game. You play AFL you are likely to get concussed. Laura Keene, you look like a nice lady but AFL is not for you. Really that is just about the studpidest thing I've seen said on this forum, ...

5 Sinclair
4 Wilson
3 NWM
2 Wilkie
1 Marshall

5 Hill
4 Windhagar
3 Wilson
2 Garcia
1 Wilkie

no real point in explaining -- no one was exempt from blame.

5 Hill
4 Marshall
4 Steele
2 Owens

I haven't been paying attention. Have we been allocated a limited number of seats for this occasion? Are we raffling them off between ourselves? I'd be happy to attend for the 'Dogs game. But I am very happy just going with my footy gang too though. If it's competitive getting a seat I'll leave it f...

4 Battle
3 Steele
3 Hill
3 Sinclair
1 Marshall
1 NWM

I know Bonner stuffed up a number of times. (Like everyone else, I'm not convinced he's a reliable enough defender.) But he had almost twice as many kicks as anyone else, and he picked up more than a kilometre's worth of metres gained. I don't recall a St Kilda player ever getting near that (since ...

Ross Marshall Steele Bonner Higgins I know Bonner stuffed up a number of times. (Like everyone else, I'm not convinced he's a reliable enough defender.) But he had almost twice as many kicks as anyone else, and he picked up more than a kilometre's worth of metres gained. I don't recall a St Kilda pl...