Jesus Christ you can't be serious.

No doubt at all that Sinclair has showed plenty of promise, BUT Schneider really should, and probably will be promoted. He's averaging over 20 disposals per game compared to Sinclair's 12.1 he also averages more tackles and marks. Don't get me wrong, Sinclair has been fantastic for us and will conti...

Late goals to Brown and Eli seal it

96-96

McCartin off with the blood rule and possible concussion

Don't like Ross and Dunstan in the same team.
Love their hardness, but can't spread, both too slow.
Only room for one IMO

Garland out is big IMHO, they don't have much experience out there as it is. I agree! Our biggest weakness is now our biggest strength. Since the Grand Finals, our forward line was just Riewoldt, but with Bruce, Billings, Lonie and the Mids kicking goals our forward line is suddenly so dynamic, and...

Who stops Garlett?
He's too quick for Geary!

Rosco wrote:Howe down back? Membrey?

The emergence of Bruce this year is such a godsend.
If Mcdonald goes to Bruce then Fitzpatrick goes to Riewoldt, and vice versa.

Dunn probably a better fit for Membrey body wise.
I personally always liked Howe more as a forward though

felix wrote:Howe ? He is tuff to match up on ...who can run with him ..Gilbert ?

It depends if he plays forward or back!

But the one thing we seem to have an abundance of is medium defenders.

Gilbo, Roberton, Dempster, Webster could all go with him I feel.

[b]https://thebeardedbugle.wordpress.com/2015/06/11/st-kilda-v-melbourne-is-no-longer-a-pointless-game/[/b] "This Sunday marks a significant milestone for both the St.Kilda and Melbourne Football clubs - it’s the first time in a long time that anyone outside the supporters of each club actuall...

Also, Noticed today that the page has a sponsor in Red Rooster in Seaford. Now I understand how to make money through advertisment on social media, I've done it a little on instagram. But if whoever runs the page is making money off the St.Kilda name, shouldn't itbe going to the club?? Just a though...

Thanks for the input guys.

Strange that the club lets the page run, In my eyes it just takes away from the official Saints page.

The club has been really good on social media in the post Ross Lyon era.

He does a really good job on that Facebook page. Weird dude tho. You sure he has done a good job on the Facebook page? Some issues with sponsorship money, I have been told. You could be right. I only bother reading the posts and articles, which is pretty informative. I've never been that involved w...

Bunk_Moreland wrote:

Old Mate wrote:He does a really good job on that Facebook page. Weird dude tho.

You sure he has done a good job on the Facebook page?

Some issues with sponsorship money, I have been told.

Sticky Fingers?

Anyone know who runs the saints foot facebook page?
Are they aligned with the club or is it just a fan?

I didn't know we were after Liam

It has gotten quite a bit of coverage lately that David Armitage sat down with Richo and spoke about emulating Jordan Lewis and it has done wonders for Armo. I think Richo/Skrobalak/Kingsley could do worse than sit down with Bill and go through Todd Goldstein's tapes. I think Billy has the ability ...

Goddard to debut, great week to Cam to swap with him cause of height only Out Longer, Shenton, Schneider In Membrey, Goddard, Weller Wouldn't mind Minch getting a turn, at who's expenses? Sinclair, he's had a great run and exceeded all expectations. Hits the scoreboard but doesn't do much else. Is ...

dragit wrote:In
Gilbert Dunstan Weller membrey

Out
Shenton ross Newnes hickey

What is the point in swapping Dunstan for Ross?
Like for like players. Dunstan has been ordinary for most of the year. Let Ross havea run and let Dunstan find some form in the VFL.

Ins ?? Outs Hickey - awkward slow Schneider - give young player his spot - minchington. Ray - some talent but time to give Wright this spot Ross - too slow no urgency. Shenton - runs out of legs early Hickey and Longer are getting less potent every week Schneider was terrific tonight wont get dropp...

Why was hickey subbed, give the ruck a chance in the ruck 100% agree Why play him forward when he is clearly a ruckman, only to sub him without giving him ago as a ruck. I understand needing another tall for structure, but he offers next to nothing. At least give Lee, Membrey or someone else ago (Y...

Shenton has been fine. Tries his backside off. Not doubting his effort at all SainterK. But just because a player TRIES his hardest, doesn't mean there isn't a better option. Just like Jonesy before him, tries his best but isn't really up to it IMO Maybe I'm wrong, but he's done nothing to set the ...

Don't like the idea of dropping Ray or Schneider. Schneider has been one of our best all year and Ray is still streets ahead or Wright. The balance between youth and experience still has to be monitored. Wright, McKenzie, Shenton all fight and rotate for positions. Sinclair has shown plenty in goal ...

We got smashed in the middle. Hickey as a forward isn't working. Longer wins the hitouts but we get smashed in the middle and he is a donkey around the ground. I'm not Shenton bashing, but I just don't like him in the team. He's okay, but that's it, okay skills, okay defensively but that's it. Good ...

Aside from some obvious skill errors and many easy dropped marks (I think that just came down to some real tired bodies) I think it was a pretty good game from the boys today. Hawks are elite and at times we moved the ball really well and made them look silly/slow, we also had a very terrible turnov...