Killa wrote: ↑Mon 01 Jul 2024 3:31pm And Marshall can not play as a forward

Nuff said

Neither can Max King

The complete lack of compassion for the guy shown by Scollop, 6oclock, DB & chook23 is a revelation, but not completely surprising I suppose. Poor form. You left me out If you can't play for any reason or excuse, you are of no use. Trade him for whatever you can get. Might get a third rounder.

Battle for pick 19 would be a(nother) list management disaster for us. Agreed, Battle for pick 19 St Kilda should match Hawthorn offer Pick 5 for Battle after pick 4 could deliver 2 desperately needed good midfielders. I would hate to see Battle go but he is half way through his playing career so w...

Has to be dropped We doesn't want a contest And doesn't want the ball Wtf is wrong with him? He looks like his confidence is completely shot. Why though? Just trots around Nothing to do with confidence, it is a matter of no determination, lazy bum. If St Kilda can get a top 40 pick for him TRADE.

One game does not make a career. But he looks like a footballer, unlike Webster who never did and isn't. Is he capable and willing to learn the art of defence? The next 4 years will tell. The Tasmanians will get AFL assistance to entice all their Tassie players to go home, once they are settingup t...

Wasn’t in the contest and chose to stand 5m over the mark 🙈 Why wasn’t it 50 when the Lions player gave the ball to Butler even though the free kick wasn’t his. Because as the umpire said, Butler called for the ball Serious stop crying about every single thing So he gave the Brisbane player a warni...

The Fireman wrote: ↑Sat 15 Jun 2024 12:23am All umpires should be sacked

No, John Setka was quite specific.
Only the umpires boss.
Sacking all the umpires would be bullying.

Impressive debut - that first kick was sublime So if stats mean anything 2nd most kicks at 15 (damn you Sinclair) Equal 4th disposals at 18 2nd most meters gained at 454 (damn you Sinclair) All told, I wouldnt write him off yet and I 'd hold my fire on calling him a fluke 3rd most marks Damn Wilkie...

Schoenmaker played very well for a 1st gamer. Battle was very poor so was Cordy. What do you mean. Cordy's two handballs were really good and his one tackle spectacular. The rest of his game, well he took up space on the ground. Would have had better stats if the ball had stopped avoiding him. Mayb...

D.B.Cooper wrote: ↑Thu 16 May 2024 1:35pm Who thinks Heath will make it at AFL level?

Good competitor, hard nosed but I don't think he has it for athleticism and running capacity to be an AFL ruck.

Heath will only make it as an AFL ruckman after St Kilda delist him.

I'm kind of sick of people making excuses for King- he got flogged last night and only looked slightly better when he went up the field. He is one of our luckiest players in that regards being the constant and readily available supply of excuses. He just doesn’t use his tools to work hard enough to...

I'm kind of sick of people making excuses for King- he got flogged last night and only looked slightly better when he went up the field. And the Coleman medalist leader at the other end dominated the game, after his opponent went off in the first 20 minutes People on here are hilarious I remember w...

Webster was well beaten by Long tonight Slipping over constantly He’s a good player but I think we need to find a better one Long had 10 and a goal was being pumped up for chasing people. Long got 4 tackles, 10 disposals, meanwhile Flanders got 2 tackles, 42 disposals but no praise for his effort.

Did Cordy get through the game ok ? We may need him next week . Schoenmaker did not play. he was probably the emergency at Docklands I hope they use Howard's injury to give Schoenmaker a game. Cordy knows the defensive role able to silence his opponent if he has help but that is all he does. Caught...

Did Cordy get through the game ok ? We may need him next week . Schoenmaker did not play. he was probably the emergency at Docklands I hope they use Howard's injury to give Schoenmaker a game. Cordy knows the defensive role able to silence his opponent if he has help but that is all he does. Caught...

desertsaint wrote: ↑Sun 09 Jun 2024 2:02am teams do have a habit of losing the week after playing us.

Especially if they have their Harley nicked.

Norf will be looking for a full forward.
A straight trade King for LDU.
If only to spare St Kilda supporters the angst of King's histrionics.

Winx or a wimp He may be able to run fast but he never uses that speed to get separation on a lead. Once an opponent with the ball has 2 metres on him he is too lazy to chase HARD to apply pressure, just gives up after jogging a few steps. If you could get a top 5 draft pick in exchange I would trad...

Sorry Loris but it's Martial Arts. In any event the young guy has anger management issues and is a would be thug. Thanks saynta. At least I got the pronunciation right eh? I think he showed his frustrations, when he couldn’t control his game output. Lot to learn, only young, still has pimples on hi...

Did not play Tom Campbell Isaac Keeler Ben Paton Zac Jones Lance Collard Normally only one player from the emergencies travels - Campbell, Paton, Jones But maybe all 3 travelled Definitely injured James Van Es Jack Hayes Zaine Cordy Liam Stocker (not listed but definitely injured) So what is the sto...

Reid will win a Brownlow If you can’t see how good he is then sorry mate. What can I say .? Windy showed that Harley Reid can be tagged out of the game. Only arrogant coaches will have one of their players go head to head with him instead of tagging. It would only prove the AFL to be corrupt if he ...

Elephants are not fragile.
Has there ever been a player more fragile than King.

Hawthorn stole 4 points off St Kilda giving St Kilda a md season pick ahead of them. St Kilda has stolen Max Hall out from under their noses. Hawthorn is likely to have picked him but St Kilda had the pick before them. Welcome Max Go some way to making up for McKenzie one of our NGA players that th...

The Fireman wrote: ↑Thu 30 May 2024 10:13pm Barry’s son ?

Can't be, apparently of good character.

No E gets to play but Crouch who has done even better the last 2 matches at Sandringham does not.
But they play different roles in the midfield.