tony74 wrote: ↑Sat 03 Aug 2024 10:13am I can 100% assure you we will not pay overs. Josh will do what’s best for his family-as he should

Then why are the Saints paying overs for a big sook to stand in the goal square while his opponent makes it easy for oppositions to exit 50.
Winx more like Wimp.

Zac f****** Jones!!!! WTAF do the selection panel see in this muppet, an absolute turnover king He knows what is required. Team must lose for better draft picks. Honourable loses have more value than wins for the next 6 games Has had a good career so the club does not appear to be tanking by playin...

Put draft pick 4 and pick 5 (Battle compensation) in the middle.
That is where you play the best midfielders.
I don't their names but they had better be superb.
No more wasting top picks on low probably full forwards.

The big positive = forced Adelaide above St Kilda on the ladder. Lets not get carried away with winning. Close enough is good enough. If Hawthorn steals Battle for mid 1st round compensation then St Kilda get double value for finishing low on the ladder. Keep playing Membrey, sadly he has forgotten ...

Love the improvement in Phillipou.
Can now call him by his full name

Better draft pick Phillipous gradual evolution into a genuine match winner. Sharman providing the forward effort we have lacked all year Normal gun performances from Milera, Marshall and Steele Obvious class of Clark Lacked a bit of luck. Dry game and we win imo. Sharman for a fraction of the cost ...

The only thing that would prevent Cameron from getting 2 weeks would be AFL corruption.

What a pity Daicos didn't get two of concussion as well.

I still sadly remember Robert Harvey’s speech when he won his first Brownlow Medal. Chris Grant received more votes than Harves, Grant had been reported & suspended during the year so he was ineligible to win the Charlie. Poor Harves, the humble man that he was/is, said words to the effect that...

Nothing that a super model girl friend couldn't cure.

bobmurray wrote: ↑Fri 12 Jul 2024 7:23pm Interesting that Hall is not named in Sandy's team for Sunday against Willy.

That goal to goal line looks way too tall to be playing kindergarten football !

Aww - I thought you were going to say that they were going to Loose the Moose! Who does Moose need to lock antlers with to get a game in the seniors? Max Hall must be doing something right, all the same. Maybe the Moose's papers have been stamped. It is terribly inconvenient when a player is given ...

The standout among successful business is the ability and capacity of the Board And, on a Board, courtesy of the responsibilities and that no one is expert on everything, the Board Members are appointed because of their expertise, complementing the performance of the Board across its responsibiliti...

Sydney have shown all season they are a better team without Buddy
St Kilda showed they are better team without King.
It helps when you have 6 forwards willing to chase and tackle instead of sulking over poor delivery.
King allows opposition teams a spare player to run the ball out of defence.

66Iwasthere wrote: ↑Sat 06 Jul 2024 2:22pm Time with his twin in the warmer weather might help

What would Gold Coast give to make that permanent.
They don't need Noah Anderson do they.

King Max wrote: ↑Thu 04 Jul 2024 8:04pm I’m prepared to bet anyone here any amount of money, that we will win another flag in my lifetime.

Somehow I don't think that you intend to pay up as you go to join the Saints in heaven.

In a few years maybe I will be able to get ChatGPT to produce a video of St Kilda winning an AFL Grand Final.
I could pretend that it were real instead of just an artificial intelligence production.

Killa wrote: ↑Mon 01 Jul 2024 3:31pm And Marshall can not play as a forward

Nuff said

Neither can Max King

The complete lack of compassion for the guy shown by Scollop, 6oclock, DB & chook23 is a revelation, but not completely surprising I suppose. Poor form. You left me out If you can't play for any reason or excuse, you are of no use. Trade him for whatever you can get. Might get a third rounder.

Battle for pick 19 would be a(nother) list management disaster for us. Agreed, Battle for pick 19 St Kilda should match Hawthorn offer Pick 5 for Battle after pick 4 could deliver 2 desperately needed good midfielders. I would hate to see Battle go but he is half way through his playing career so w...

Has to be dropped We doesn't want a contest And doesn't want the ball Wtf is wrong with him? He looks like his confidence is completely shot. Why though? Just trots around Nothing to do with confidence, it is a matter of no determination, lazy bum. If St Kilda can get a top 40 pick for him TRADE.

One game does not make a career. But he looks like a footballer, unlike Webster who never did and isn't. Is he capable and willing to learn the art of defence? The next 4 years will tell. The Tasmanians will get AFL assistance to entice all their Tassie players to go home, once they are settingup t...

Wasn’t in the contest and chose to stand 5m over the mark 🙈 Why wasn’t it 50 when the Lions player gave the ball to Butler even though the free kick wasn’t his. Because as the umpire said, Butler called for the ball Serious stop crying about every single thing So he gave the Brisbane player a warni...

The Fireman wrote: ↑Sat 15 Jun 2024 12:23am All umpires should be sacked

No, John Setka was quite specific.
Only the umpires boss.
Sacking all the umpires would be bullying.

Impressive debut - that first kick was sublime So if stats mean anything 2nd most kicks at 15 (damn you Sinclair) Equal 4th disposals at 18 2nd most meters gained at 454 (damn you Sinclair) All told, I wouldnt write him off yet and I 'd hold my fire on calling him a fluke 3rd most marks Damn Wilkie...

Schoenmaker played very well for a 1st gamer. Battle was very poor so was Cordy. What do you mean. Cordy's two handballs were really good and his one tackle spectacular. The rest of his game, well he took up space on the ground. Would have had better stats if the ball had stopped avoiding him. Mayb...