St Kilda's pick 25 has already become pick 28 due to first round (Band 1) compensation for Battle & Perryman and end of first round (Band 2) for Isaac Cummings. That will slip further because of father son and academy picks for Levi Ashcroft, Sam Marshall, Isaac Kako & Leo Lombard. That make...

skeptic wrote: ↑Fri 04 Oct 2024 9:00pm How much of a power position do North have?

Get something for him now or lose him as a free agent in 12 months?

They would get a top 3 draft pick as compensation (depending on where they finish), that is what he is worth to North in a years time.

Give North our first 3 picks that is picks 7 & 8 and 25 as they stand now in return for pick 2 and LDU. But we would have LDU and the 3rd best midfielder from the draft. But I am only dreaming because it values LDU at a little over 1400 points before and after all the draft compensations & f...

What's the fuss, he is already wearing a Hawthorn jumper. He is yesterday's man.

Would you consider splitting the picks Pick 8 for 15 & 20 Giving us picks 7, 15, 20, 25 I would prefer to explore going the other way. The very best midfielders in this draft will be gone at pick 8 (St Kilda first pick after Brisbane steals Ashcroft) As it stands Richmond has pick 1 (3000 point...

Some stupid idiot just signed Max King to a new deal that extends him to the end of 2032. Can't get rid of him now without looking dumber than dumb. You have to take risks to be on top of the game. Hopefully the media loud mouths and foul weather supporters will learn a few things during the next 8...

St Kilda presently has pick 7 & 8 but those will certainly slip as Brisbane will queue jump to take father/son Ashcroft.

Some stupid idiot just signed Max King to a new deal that extends him to the end of 2032.
Can't get rid of him now without looking dumber than dumb.

Ball checked out? Had a pretty fair GF for someone who checked out. That’s the biggest load of rubbish I’ve ever heard. Tampering He went through to the ND and went at pick 30 - could’ve gone anywhere The fact that we got zero for him - our fault - offered a second rounder! We (Ross) fkd that up co...

It would have been a travesty if Cripps hadn't won. He certainly was the best player this season, by a fair margin. But I agree that 45 votes was ludicrous. And even more ludicrous was how much the possession-gatherers dominated the votes this season: more than I can ever remember. The top ten incl...

Round 17 v Sydney The POE was robbed Was BOG according to both coaches But the whistle blowers did not even give him one vote . Round 20 v Essendon The Sharman was robbed Was BOG according to both coaches But the whistle blowers did not even give him one vote Rumour is Essendon put weed in their whi...

If Ivan Soldo comes in, it would mean Jack Hayes will not get a contract.

But we selected Billings at pick 3.

I can't guarantee that I will live long enough to see the end of the sook.

I have been waiting 58 years for another premiership, why won't the club let me see another ?

They got them all as First Round Picks They didn’t get the as well as first round picks Good talent identity (as kids) Good recruiting Good development Good culture We had gifts as well Pick 3 Pick 1 In those drafts Chose McCartin and Billings Would Petracca and Bontempelli instead have helped ? Bu...

nostalgicsaint wrote: ↑Tue 17 Sep 2024 1:40pm Sat next to Morris at a Cafe this morning.

He was meeting Dan H about working on trade week radio.

They were talking about this topic.

He told hanners the deal would be 7m over 5 years.

Hanners said I don't get out of bed for a Big m.

Brad Scott
Dragged North to the bottom of the ladder, left them to go do the same to Essendon.

Seems Gold Coast is happy for Lukosius to go elsewhere probably Adelaide

But what about a straight swap for Max King.
Max would love to join his brother and relieve Saints fans of their frustrations.

St Kilda would normally have 4 picks in the national draft Based on finishing position those should be 7, 25, 43, 61 But the corrupt AFL has given Norf two freebies at the end of the first round So that would make St Kilda picks 7, 27, 45, 63 In all the trading of players before and on draft night 2...

Judd was better at West Coast. Didn't it work out: Kennedy, Masten & Notte verses Judd & Armfield WIN/WIN West Coast got more years out of Kennedy because Judd's career was half over by the time he moved to Carlton. If St Kilda had used the pick they gave to Essendon for Carlisle wisely tha...

Just another first round draft pick DUD.
TRADE HIM but don't expect much for him.

Noting we know nothing of the specific contractual arrangements; and its becoming clearer, is it not, that contracts between clubs and players are tending towards becoming more statements of intent and ways to fix salary levels than binding mutual obligations. Its now discretionary for players to s...

The_Dud wrote: ↑Sat 31 Aug 2024 11:13am What’s actually stopping him from going to the footy again?

The AFL has cameras at every entrance and around the ground with face and body recognition software.
They will also have secret police watching and reporting his every move when he leaves his home.

Other than that it all a bluff.

Battle has been very good for us in the past three seasons. Very hard to replace. No doubt we'll get screwed over with the change in the rules around compensation. Funny how the rules change in the very years we are in line to benefit. It's almost as if the AFL is watching our club and waiting for ...