him at number 1 for a while,perplexing? Adam Goodes-it's not his fault that he's won 2 brownlows,but the worst dual brownlow medalist there is,and the scary thing is,the way the umps love him for getting a whopping 17 touches a match that are all uncontested out on the wing/half back flank,he could...

roger from wa I think some of your instructions date back to the 70s "don't let him get a touch" , "don't even think of getting a kick" .. it's not that simple anymore and the game is played differently I believe that the saints play a game where they are happy and don't mind to ...

ah my pet subject

easily Dustin Fletcher

hardly ever gets the number one forward, and then get 30 kicks playing on his shadow

soft sniper, has been reported heaps and still only ever gets a week

have to disagree with those saying goodes, thomas and judd

fqf

Well with the NAB practice games we do know that the coaching staff used quite a number of the players in different roles and for varying amounts of ground time with many rotations used just to get match time into the fringe. Winning the games was not a priority....giving everyone game time and bei...

No doubt Milne had a good game last night. No doubt he'll have bad ones throughout the year, and he'll continue to have his fans and detractors. What really pleased me from Milne last night was a defensive effort, on Macleod... Ball came in and Milne managed to spoil it to the ground (not a skill I...

The drafting during the GT period has cost us some much needed depth that we could have used now. It's good to see that it has changed the past couple of years because the draft is very important and should be taken very seriously. I think we had the depth ,we just had shocking injury runs. No team...

did you see the benchs faces in the last quarter do you think they take it seriously? I think it comes back to bite the teams that don't take it seriously eg swans yes they won a flag (when they had incredible luck with injuries) but now the swans have no list to speak of from player 25 on , because...

can't believe comments saying nothing in the brown hit it was as cheap and cowardly as anything you could see on the field, yes he was only winded that is not the point, we don't want to see that in the game if it was a saints player he had hit we would be screaming for his head. lucky to get two, n...

I doubt this would ever happen with Suspensions/ Injuries etc. but on the fringes Milne, Gram , Fiora. Just behind Blake, Jones. Gram on the fringes? Are you on crack? wouldn't have put it quite like that but.................. gram is easily in the best 12 players, and is vital for the make up of t...

does anyone know if this guy is the son of John Geary who was a great country footballer

captained Redan in the late 70sand was as hard as

cheers

thought baker was excellent and gram once he warmed up

but overall joey was my number 1

cheers joffaboy

sitting here enjoying a beer, with not a care

how you can be critical of any player after that win is beyond my comprehension

I thought the last quarter was sensational bunch of kids up against a power team, if we lost by 3 goals we would have all been saying, gutsy effort considering, so to win! wow let the kids enjoy the moment........... no lid, let it bubble and boil many of them will walk taller for weeks on that fqf

did some of you people watch the game? seriously I thought it was an almost career turning game for milne, in the last quarter he became a leader, with so many missing. he went and filled holes, he went back, he was critical in the winning goal, and his kick fup the wing with 55 seconds on the clock...

i thought the jumper matched the team.. disgraceful

it looked like something that had gone in the colour wash at home and got slightly stained

2007 was a very poor year, with no stand-out performances. The win against Melbourne in Round 1 was put into context by the season Melbourne had. There is a need for improvement, including an improvement in fitness and focus, across the club. When we somehow scraped into the eight late in the seaso...

definitely in the wet (make that very wet) against the swans in 06 at scg, last quarter slog and then nick's mark

we were all on the ground that night bottling up the defence

fqf

can't believe that mirror went for that much on ebay

came out in the late 70s early 80s and were pretty shabby from memory

oh well there is always an ebay sucker somewhere

sensational

made all the more poignant with the wonderful Clinton doing the call

fqf

no worries

it will never be for sale so does not matter

fqf

no Robbie Muirs brother did not, but it sort adds a certain something to all the signatures, as Robbie did not player until a few years later I once met Mad Dog, and I never played for the Saints, does that qualify me to sign the jumper? :shock: it is actually a footy record and I think it adds a l...

no Robbie Muirs brother did not, but it sort adds a certain something to all the signatures, as Robbie did not player until a few years later

i have a gf record signed by players from both sides as a young boy managed to get in the rooms after the game

the best signature on it however is when i took it to school on monday and Robbie Muir's brother who was at my school added his signature to it,

fqf

don't quite know how Yze gets on an overrated list

in his prime was a great player, suddenly age and injury took their toll and he became a bit player, so not sure that he is rated over or under, just does what he does

overrated

number 1

Dustin Fletcher

number 2 daylight

fqf

j.blake