Don't want to be negative after the last two weeks and the win against the Swans, but I honestly don't know what we do with King. I honestly feel that we play better without him.

saynta wrote: ↑Sat 20 Jul 2024 5:49pm 5. Membrey
4. Sinclair
3. Wood
1. Marshall
1. Steele
1. Jones

This.

bobmurray wrote: ↑Tue 09 Jul 2024 9:00pm Hard to know how we would have gone with Max playing against the Swans, simply because the players up the ground seem to always want to bomb it to Max. Which would have changed some of our forward entries.

Exactly what I was thinking. And I'll bet we would have lost as a result.

Really feel for Max King. I think it would be both in his interests and that of the club if he found a new home next year - he seems desperately unhappy and lady luck is just not smiling on him with his constant injuries. I think he needs a change of scenery and in return I expect the Saints would ...

Bakes would have got 6 weeks.

Really feel for Max King. I think it would be both in his interests and that of the club if he found a new home next year - he seems desperately unhappy and lady luck is just not smiling on him with his constant injuries. I think he needs a change of scenery and in return I expect the Saints would ...

Don't want to moz them, but our defence has been exceptional.

So many inside 50s without scoring. No apparent strategies. We could be 5 goals in front.

A few years back, Channel 7 always had a North Melbourne training story and a Ziebell interview with him saying something to the effect that they were planning on doing better next weekend! Channel 9 news always has a Collingwood story, usually about one of their injured players who is back running ...

Gives every impression of playing under sufferance. Question is whether he doesn't want to play or just doesn't want to play for us.

Brilliant today!

Ludicrous decision but, let's face it, Bakes would have got 7 weeks.

No-one standing on the line.

Umpires have lost the plot.

Dropped marks shouldn't be a turnover every time.

For the 2nd game in a row, all 14 sports journalists in The Age have picked us to win. It's a real worry. Sportsbet gives us $1.32 or something, Tigers longer odds. Weird. But if you believe tipsters have any influence on 23 young blokes, I worry for your sanity 😳😖 I always see it asa bad omen! 😉

For the 2nd game in a row, all 14 sports journalists in The Age have picked us to win. It's a real worry.

Horrendous turnovers

King does some weird things

So far, way too many aimless kicks out of defence onto the chest of Collingwood players.

Slowing the game down. Short passes. Turnovers. Playing into their hands.

Umpiring didn't affect the result but there were some truly surreal moments that made you completely uncertain as to might be coming next: Two totally unnecessary score reviews. One where everyone in the ground could see that it was a behind to GWS and couldn't possibly be anything else. The other w...

1971 Prelim. Beat Richmond on their home ground. Dared to dream then, too.

saynta wrote: ↑Thu 10 Aug 2023 11:08am

terry smith rules wrote: ↑Thu 10 Aug 2023 11:06am Of course they play St K FC

Good riddance.....sniper.

Just logged in to see whether there was a Cotchin thread with the intention of posting exactly this.

CURLY wrote: ↑Sat 08 Jul 2023 10:13pm Howard smothered after taking a mark has to be 50


May tackled throws the ball out as clear as you like Melbourne goal

It was a 50 every day of the week. Why was the free retaken from the same spot?