Why do you guarantee that?

Yeah I reckon he’s earned his way back in.

The other one that’s caught my eye is Heath. Reckon he might be worth a go too

I’m not sure how a guy can be better in his 3rd year than his 7th?! He has lost all confidence He made Zerk Thatcher look like Stephen Silvagni! Wasn’t launching at it, leading at it, all he does is run around in circles and lose wrestles What do you think it is BM? Because I’m kind of with you in ...

B.M wrote: ↑Sun 30 Jun 2024 9:25pm I thought we beat them in the COVID year under Ratten in Adelaide?

Yeah that’s right. We put on a clinic that night

Talent doesn’t go away. He is much better than how he’s playing at the moment.

I just wish I knew what was going wrong for him

5. Sinclair
4. Marshall
3. Wilkie
2. NWM
1. Steele

Shout out to Coops who came on in the last to kick a big goal and set up another

Yeah. Really disappointed in Dow. Hasn’t come on at all like I hoped.

A fully fit Crouch would have been the difference

It’s so weird because 12 months he was a dead eye dick with those snap shots.

I can’t remember the others specifically but the Butler one with Alir was a shocker and there were a few non holding the balls with Port players in the last that weren’t paid but we copped it consistently on the other end

I personally agree with Curly on the Marshall 50m. He took the mark, stopped and then was cannoned into the back late and put to ground.

That’s 50m every day of the week in every interpretation.

That would have been a goal from the square and possibly the difference

Umpire just wins them the game Keep cryin Curly! 😭😭😭😭😭 In fairness… I thought they were bad in the last 1/4 and a half. A number of 50s that should have been paid for late contact and I saw a number of holds off the contest that weren’t paid. Wouldn’t bother me normally but Port got all the 50/50s ...

I don’t understand why he doesn’t push up the ground more… def looks more effective as part of the transition

Not necessarily featuring in the votes but I thought he had a big second half and almost won us the game

I gotta say… whilst the free vs King for late was there… the 50/50s are overwhelmingly going Porta way

The holding ball rule deserves the criticism it’s got today

Sharman again… set up Higgins there

bobmurray wrote: ↑Sun 30 Jun 2024 4:11pm The Sharmanator takes a great grab and goals.

This is the post that makes me realise that my Kayo in delayed by about 10s. Thanks for the spoiler

There’s my boy

Geeez I hate to see mids lead with the head into a contest

:evil: King has gone backwards under Ross Lyon It doesn't matter how many talented kids we bring into this team. At least Phillipou is now getting a bit of propper development away from the messiah I think King just doesn’t fit into the Ross game style. Either utilise him or move him on while he’s ...

Owens should have just had the shot

King has gone backwards under Ross Lyon It doesn't matter how many talented kids we bring into this team. At least Phillipou is now getting a bit of propper development away from the messiah I think King just doesn’t fit into the Ross game style. Either utilise him or move him on while he’s still g...

I’ll pay a comment that that should have been 50 for Marshall

Just FYI,

There’s a few expressions of displeasure about various posting habits on this thread obviously RE the umpiring and other things. I’ve reached out to everyone and will keep an eye on this more closely in the second half.

Carry on

For anyone watching the game… I see Josh Sinn, the player many wanted before NWM has 6 touches. Obviously no one has any buyers remorse on that one but any observations on this kid?