i only go by what i've read here but one benefit with Silvagni is that we need a kid that can start playing in the backline... NOW'ish if u draft a new KPP ur looking at at least 2-3 seasons of devolpment (by playing in the VFL) and that means that Maxy, who is clearly past his best and should be wi...

at least he's 1 player who when delisted there will be no ??? over him

unlike Brooks, Murray, Watts, McGough etc and pbly Ferguson too

i suspect that saying they'll consider an appeal is just a red herring (if i'm using the term correctly) to rule out an appeal right away may incur the wrath of a vocal group that for whatever reason think GT shouldn't have gotten anything or should have got less. It sounds much better to say "...

could make a career as a bit player that comes into the team only to play on opposition quickish forwards when need be

Don't think I've read the name Heath Black yet... as i've posted many times... supremely talented player who was good enough to be 1 of the competition's elite... after his best season of footbal he pi$$ed of back to Freo to play cheap, pass me the ball off the HBF footy and stopped doing the hard t...

i think the game has gone past players that can't do a lot of running

i think we may be better off resting midfielders at this time give chances to whichever medium sized forward is in the team at that time... Allen, Charlie, Mac, Raph etc

+ don't forget that Roo would still drop down

if u go through the threads (and I said this at the time) a bunch of childish forumites started with the personal insults and name calling. It was totally uncalled for and unprovoked love him or hate him, St. Mart has always been about the football... isn't interested in name calling, insults and sl...

more than a few teams in the top 8 would at least be weary of playing us in a final in Melbourne...

if we do make the finals... we're more than capable of getting deep into september and causing some pain

it seems that Kosi needs to play in the ruck or at least spend significant periods of the game rucking to get more in the action (resulting in him playing better). makes me wonder if having all 3 of King, Gardiner and Kosi in the team = us being too top heavy as it robs us of an additional running m...

is anybody else worried about the change of affiliations... it's fair to say that the Saints/Casey relationship is now blossoming after 5-6 years of work going into it and now we've switched to a club which Melb supporters claim is difficult to work with. it seems to me that we've got a really good ...

I'd hate to see either Eddy or Gwilt go... both seem to be getting better each week

seemes to me that perhaps one of Allan or C. Gardiner should go for Hayes

I got into the car just as the broadcast finished

thanks in advance

such as...

C. Gardiner?

Sainternist wrote:

BigMart wrote:We could win the premiership under Osama bin Ladan for all I care....so a wins a win, but

Hey, Osama would make a fine coach. Would make sure his players got things done hook or by crook. Seemed to have coached his terrorists well before the big kaboom.

hmmm... swing and a miss

will Armo make way for Hayes?

quite enjoyed that win... only saw the first and last 1/4s on TV and got my updates from SS

though we're on par for the finals... i might just wiat until we beat some really credible opposition b4 i declare that RL is the master and that we've turned the corner

first time in a long time that we've shown a bit of resolve

first time in a long time a little bit of sun has crept through the clouds

feels good

lol despite the vast difference in opinion, note which forumites are interested in debate and which ones went straight for the name calling

I'm not a Blake fan at all, but it seems to me that his performance has improved significantly over the last 6 weeks and he's become more of a genuine backmen (didn't c the game 2nite) rather than a floater utility

bobmurray wrote:I'm going to the game on Sunday providing it's not Raining,looking forward to seeing them play....

Hey bob

could u pay particular attention to the performances of Raph, Birss and Miles for me please?

lol this thread he's not in a position to choose a club :? He's an absolute GUN. I think you'll find AT LEAST 6 clubs minimum will move heaven and earth to get him. Okay so the Roos and Blues are out... fair enough. Could easily be the last piece of the premiership puzzle for Hawthorn, Collingwood o...

\ Do you agree with me or just interesting. Would love to know what others think. Especially those who have seen him play well at Casey Yes I do actually. He hasn't played a lot of footy but gets judged like a senior player coz he's been on the list for 5 years. I'd love to see him come into the te...

NoMore wrote:Also think that they use R Clarke much better at this level which is a reason he does a little better. Needs to be eased into AFL a bit. Not given a big forward every week.

interesting

i'd be surprised f he stayed in the 2s any longer... at least for now.

Big game next week VS the Roos... winner in the 8. With Hayes and Ball hitting form my bet would now is the time for 1 last tilt