i don't know that getting one means losing the other

perhaps we're just increasing resources in that department (wishful thinking)

Won't play - unfortunately. Born running half back - 100% better when his brother plays too. Thinks quicker than he acts, unlike Gilbert who acts without thinking! Will play. What does that mean. Of course he is not playing. Who said he was? you didn't Look at my unoriginal post! I love GT. Not Con...

surely after rushing players back too qquickly time and time again nobody seriously wants to risk x 2 weeks into his comeback?

case in point Stephen Kernahan... one of the all time Carlton greats. Could barely kick the ball 40m, not a particuarly accurate kick, was just an ok mark and rarely took games apart like the other great CHFs of his time. Yet he was made to look like a champion CHF because he played in a champion te...

fair point

skeptic..... you'e a dead set dill..... trade baker... yeah ok..... i guess adelaide should trade mcleod... eagles glass...... dogs johnson..... hawks crawford..... roos rawlings...... tigers coghlan...... swans crouch...... their best form is past all of them.... but they are the life and soul of ...

We should 'never ever' trade someone like Baker. He has worked too hard and done so much. His type of player gives the club its passion - because he is a Saint in heart and soul. if u could get a 2nd round or early 3rd round pick for him in the most talent soaked draft of all time you'd be foolish ...

don't need SHaw

Didak would be a good fit for us but i'd rather go through the draft this season

IMO now would be the time to trade him

we've got plenty of others that can fill this role

take 2

just get us a good home base and now

i can't believe collingwood actually has the spine to suspend 2 of their best players while their finals hopes hang in the balance

good on them

they've actually gained a bit of respect in my eyes

no

Too inconsistent. His best game of the year and it was against mediocre opposition and it was only a good not great game.

IMO he doesn't any significant improvement left in him, would rather see us pump games into Birss

Saint Mik wrote:RL should go and thank R. Shaw for making it just that little bit easier this week for him .

Every bit helps thank you R Shaw for being an absolute tosser

Some players just never learn hey Eddie

is that you hutchy...

up to ur old tricks i see

you'd be pretty pissed off if u were playing well and couldn't get a game ahead of some1 who has simply played stinker after stink

quite stunning

whole sale changes IMO

Kosi in for Gardiner
Gwilt in for Hudghton
Birss in for Armitage
C. Gardiner in for Schneider
Geary in for Fiora

I like the look of it

St DAC wrote:
If it looks like a turd, and smells like a turd ...

what does it taste like?

i reckon we'll go to Frankston park

sure there's a cost blow out of a couple of million, but we'll earn that back in a year or 2-3

it's clearly the prime location

x and kosi suffered from being pushed too hard too early

as a result their bodies became very very fragile...

a prolonged rest is what will do the trick

now X hasn't had this but with Kosi got it due constant impact injuries, that's why he is now on the park and x is not

agree with Teffers,

Birss in, Schneider out

would certainly improve my perception of the coach

well we knew Attard would miss all season when we retained him on the list...

i suspect he'd already done enough

gotta side with WJ here

Gardiner has played a few good games this season... Rix has not and cannot

Well it's his second year on the rookie list which means he has to be either promoted or demoted at the end of the season. His seasons over so i guess this one has already been put to bed what do you think, stay or go? suffice to say that he hasn't impressed much but (so the tale goes) has a lot of ...

boy we were exposed w/o his flexibility eh?