The question is, who is the best CHF. Loewe VS Roo. Answer: Loewe is the better true CHF than Roo. Also remember that Loewe was in a team that had the best FF in history of the game. Roo maybe a better player on and off the field, but to play CHF now and in there primes Loewe was better. Also Loewe ...

ray should play forward.

Also isolate him there with the right match up as he is fast, strong overhead and reliable kick normally.
Would be hard to match up on.
He seems to go missing down back to often as we have other players to fill his role.
Could be that 3rd tall that he never had.

Freo with Ross would recruit CJ, As Stephen Hill will get a kick against the saints next time we play them.

how many full backs dont rely on the second and third up. Fletcher made his name doing this.

Even Collingwoods backline looked very worried when they were one on one against geelongs acouple of weeks ago.

The best thing our Zac can do is spend summer in the gym and gain more strength.

+1

saints by 30 points

I would rather not keep a project player that is never going to get past the sandy reserves team.

If Bakes wants another year knowing he is a depth player then we keep him, you never know what can happen next year.

i believe we have not lost at Eithad on Sat nite for a long time, is that correct????

yep got mine today also. Carn the saints and lets beat the filth this week.

plugger66 wrote:I have a feeling most people can turn the sound down or even better if you are in Melbourne get to the friggin game.

Some people have to friggin work

ex footy greats need to do other games except the teams they played for as there opinions are biased. If there is gonna be a hird on TV for St kilda Vs Essendon game there needs to be Burkey or another ex or current saints player to keep the commentating unbiased. Prevoius years malcom blight's spec...

1 the importance of Mini and CJ - who ever would have thought the absence of those two would be so noticeable?


These two players are so important but who would have thought this at the start of the year. Glad to see the rookie list working for us.

just needs to stop falling over

dont ask the umpires or the afl to look into anything. We dont need any distractions, or another HEAD debarkle

should never be allowed in the back line again

Cairnsman wrote:

stinger wrote:all's well......noddy sheahan has tipped against us for the 6th week running.....

law of averages sais he will get one right soon

the law of averages means we should win every game for the next 10 years.

i agree. I sit next to the cheer squad, and the annoying young man behind me (cheer squad member) if his not commentating the game (my pet hate, ill listen to the radio if i want commentating) is either screamming kick it up the guts, grab him, dont kick backwards, our game plan is shite, why hold o...

i dont care how we win just as long as we win, whether its ugly or not. Chipping it backwards and sideways always brings us undone because we dont have the foot skills of sydney which can chip the ball around before going direct to an easy uncontested mark in the F50. Preseason needs to address our ...

needs to learn more defensive skills from the likes of baker. Needs to be bigger stronger and faster to become elite.

both kosi and dal dont stand up in losing games. would trade dal for kerr in a heart beat. At least kerr has a defensive side to his game unlike the other two. If we keep them, more likey we do both need serious conditioning. dal either needs to get bigger, stronger and tougher or run like harvey di...

i am a reserve seat member, not social club, is this register just for social club? how do reserve seat members get tickets? thanks

kosi and roo need to watch hours of brown and bradshaw tapes and have some form of gameplan. To many times do we see both go up for a mark against each other and there opponents while the ball spills to the ground. Milne is normally on a leading mission of his own and the backline gets the ball out ...

Kosi, CG, MG, X&R clake, Gwil,t fiora, L.Fisher, Fergo, Rix, armo maybe Goose

There are others but would not want to loose
Roo Lenny Goddard, Dal, Monty, Max, S.Fisher Gilbert

what about Stevie J's ran down. If that was not the perfect interpretation of holding the ball what is. A saints player getting the ball and immediately getting tackled. And the countless in the back and chopping the arms rule in the forward line. Also dont know why ottens late hit was not even sigh...

Kerr has shown that he can play in the big games and is consistent. Against Geel we had to many passengers, and if these passengers dont perform during the game against the maggies then these players need to go. BJ Lenny and Cj were the only players to hold there heads up high. Our midfield is no we...