Otiman wrote:Thanks Davo, I had us in at 9, 27, 43 again this year because I assumed Carlton got two Priority picks, one at #1 and one at #18.

I beleive you can only receive 1 type of priority pick per season. So Carlton at 1 Richmond at 18 and 19 etc

I remember about 3-4 years ago it was the big call of a race to see who would win the Premiership first StKilda or Geelong. Well we all know the answer now. Why? After even 04 and 05 , where we were probably just in front and both had sub par 06 Geelong has run ahead. Some may use the injury excuse,...

Very harsh on some: * You rate Howard an Below Average pick after 1 year when the boy weighs 70 Kilo dripping wet, yet after 3 seasons McQaulter is listed as Average . Give the boy some time please * You are very kind on Sweeney too Otherwise a very detailed review. Do you have too much spare time o...

Barker- past best by then and often injured. A great player though.

Ball Good argument , perhaps I just rated Sziller higher than most

Shannahan got S Fisher covered at this stage.1 swallow doesn't make a summer
Baker is in back pocket

I think we need pace through the middle more than anything else, therefore we need to look at who is available that can help this. Kane Tenace is one that springs to mind. Cats will have salary cap prob soon and may trade him for 2nd rounder. We should keep pick 9 , unless a no brainer trade. Bigs. ...

Sziller - you may be right but i thought really under rated

Dal - Thought about this one , and give probably 1 more year yes, but I remember Dwyer as a good midfielder who then became a goal kicking flanker, especially 1991 1992
Still could not go wrong with either

Was thinking of the best StKilda team you could put together in the last 20 years. Here is my effort: B:Shannahan, Frawley,Baker HB: Grant, Hudghton, Peckett C:McAdam, Hayes, Jones HF: Reiwoldt, Loewe, Hamill F: Gehrig, Lockett, Winmar Ruck: Everitt, Harvey, Burke Int: Dwyer, Kosi, Sziller, Thompson...

Ant thoughts on what players will be delisted or trade bait. Here's may Guess: Delisted : M Clarke F Gerhig A Thompson J Sweeney Trade Bait: X Clarke B Voss A McQaulter I expect Brooks and Watts to be kept after retirements of Clarke and Gehrig. Ferguson showed a bit as a useful back up defender and...